ConsFirst / Cookware sets / Compare
All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set vs Circulon A1 Series ScratchDefense Nonstick 9-Piece Cookware Set
Which one has the downsides you can live with?
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more
The short answer
All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set ranks higher (#1 vs #2 of 8) and scores better on useful pieces, durability (coating, warping). Circulon A1 Series ScratchDefense Nonstick 9-Piece Cookware Set wins on handles & lids, cleaning & care.
The biggest complaint about the All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set is expensive for the piece count; for the Circulon A1 Series ScratchDefense Nonstick 9-Piece Cookware Set it's exterior scratches. Pick the one whose catch bothers you less.
Side by side
| All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set | Circulon A1 Series ScratchDefense Nonstick 9-Piece Cookware Set | |
|---|---|---|
| Rank in cookware sets | #1 | #2 |
| Price tier | $$$ | $$ |
| Type | Tri-ply stainless | Nonstick (PTFE) |
| Amazon 1–2★ share | 6% | 5% |
| Overall score | 4.3 | 4.1 |
| Even heating | 5.0 | — |
| Useful pieces | 4.0 | 3.5 |
| Handles & lids | 3.5 | 4.5 |
| Cleaning & care | 4.0 | 4.5 |
| Durability (coating, warping) | 5.0 | 4.0 |
Price tiers: $ under $200 · $$ $200–500 · $$$ over $500. Highlighted = clearly better (a score gap of 0.3 or more, or a 1–2★ share at least 3 points lower). Scores are explained, with sources, on each product's page.
Top complaints
All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set
- Expensive for the piece count
Wirecutter says it is much more expensive than its top pick; Serious Eats calls it admittedly expensive; Food & Wine notes it may not come with as many pieces for the price. Amazon owners are split on weight.
- Handle shape divides people
Wirecutter says some may find the handle shape uncomfortable, Serious Eats says some folks aren't fans of the indented handles, and Food & Wine says the handles could be more comfortable.
- Sticking and discoloration
Food & Wine had some sticking when cooking rice. Amazon's summary says cleaning and sticking get mixed feedback and some owners report discoloration after first use. Wirecutter says All-Clad doesn't recommend the dishwasher.
Circulon A1 Series ScratchDefense Nonstick 9-Piece Cookware Set
- Exterior scratches
Good Housekeeping noticed light scratching on the outside of the pans, though it didn't affect performance.
Source: Good Housekeeping - Low 400°F oven limit
Food & Wine counts the 400°F temperature limit against it; Good Housekeeping also lists 400°F.
- Not the best value anymore
Food & Wine says a cheaper, more durable ceramic set (Quince) displaced it as its best-value pick.
Source: Food & Wine (nonstick sets)
Who should pick which
Pick the All-Clad D3 Tri-Ply Stainless Steel 10-Piece Cookware Set if
Buy-it-for-life stainless cookware
Sauces and caramel that need very even heat
Keeping pans looking new
Skip it if: Your budget is under $500; You dislike narrow, concave handles; You want a 12-inch skillet or nonstick in the set
Pick the Circulon A1 Series ScratchDefense Nonstick 9-Piece Cookware Set if
An affordable, easy-clean nonstick set
Straining lids and pour spouts
Dishwasher users
Skip it if: You finish dishes in a hot oven (400°F limit); You want a 12-inch skillet (it's in the 10-piece version); You want to avoid coated cookware
We don't list prices — they change daily. Paid links.