(checked 2026-10-10)
Wirecutter's pick if you don't want Amazon, and TechRadar's best budget e-reader: a sharp, waterproof, ad-free 6-inch reader with built-in library borrowing. Battery life is shorter than a Kindle's in real use, there's no cloud file transfer, and its Amazon low-star share (12%) is the highest of the mainstream readers here.
Top complaints
- Shorter real-world battery than Kindle
Kobo claims up to 53 days, but Wirecutter's reviewer got just a few weeks at higher brightness, versus about six weeks for the basic Kindle and two-plus months for the Paperwhite.
Source: Wirecutter (NYT) - Software crashes
Amazon's review summary says the software gets mixed feedback, with some owners reporting crashes.
- Small screen, plain build, no cloud transfer
TechRadar lists no cloud file transfer, a dated plastic design, and a 6-inch screen that some may find small. It also notes only Kobo-store audiobooks will play. Engadget notes Kobo's store is smaller than Kindle's.
What owners love
- Sharp, fast Carta 1300 screen
TechRadar found it the sharpest epaper display when it tested it. Wirecutter says pages turn as fast as on Kindles, with adjustable warmth. Amazon owners call the screen crystal clear.
- Easy library borrowing and open formats
Wirecutter says built-in OverDrive makes borrowing seamless. An Amazon owner notes it loads PDFs and EPUBs directly from a computer.
- Waterproof and repairable
IPX8 waterproofing (Wirecutter). TechRadar notes official iFixit spare parts and guides.
Source: Wirecutter (NYT), TechRadar
- You already own a big Kindle library
- You want the longest time between charges
- You want a screen bigger than 6 inches
- Readers who want to avoid Amazon's ecosystem
- Library borrowers (OverDrive built in)
- Sideloading EPUBs over USB
Scores (tap for why)
What experts say
- Wirecutter (NYT): Best for non-Amazon users. Its flaw is battery life that isn't quite as long as a Kindle's.
- TechRadar: Best budget pick (updated 2026-09-23), better value than the base Kindle thanks to waterproofing and a better screen. The cons are no cloud transfer and a dated plastic design.
- NBC Select: Best Kindle alternative, with long battery life (rated up to 7.5 weeks) in a compact, waterproof design.