ConsFirst / Mattress toppers / Compare
Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper vs Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper
Which one has the downsides you can live with?
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more
The short answer
Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper ranks higher (#2 vs #4 of 8) and scores better on smell & off-gassing, durability. Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper wins on comfort, stays in place.
The biggest complaint about the Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper is firmness doesn't match expectations; for the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper it's cooling doesn't work for everyone. Pick the one whose catch bothers you less.
Side by side
| Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper | Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper | |
|---|---|---|
| Rank in mattress toppers | #2 | #4 |
| Price tier | $$$ | $$$ |
| Type | Latex | Memory foam |
| Amazon 1–2★ share | — | 18% |
| Overall score | 3.9 | 3.6 |
| Comfort | 4.0 | 4.5 |
| Cooling | 3.5 | 3.5 |
| Smell & off-gassing | 4.5 | 3.5 |
| Stays in place | 3.0 | 3.5 |
| Durability | 4.5 | 3.0 |
Price tiers: $ under $100 · $$ $100–300 · $$$ over $300. Highlighted = clearly better (a score gap of 0.3 or more, or a 1–2★ share at least 3 points lower). Scores are explained, with sources, on each product's page.
Top complaints
Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper
- Firmness doesn't match expectations
Tom's Guide says it's not as plush as the name suggests, and Birch-site reviewers who were disappointed expected it thicker and plusher. AARP took the opposite view: its soft feel may not support average or heavier sleepers, and a higher-weight tester felt shoulder pressure.
Source: Tom's Guide (Birch review), AARP - Expensive
A queen lists at $532 and is usually $399 on sale (Tom's Guide); AARP calls it the most expensive on its list and Sleep Foundation calls it a bit pricey.
- No straps; non-removable cover
There are no anchor straps, and the cover can't be removed and is spot-clean only (Tom's Guide, AARP).
Source: Tom's Guide (Birch review), AARP
Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper
- Cooling doesn't work for everyone
Amazon's summary says the cooling effect divides owners, with some saying it doesn't help with overheating. Sleep Foundation's full review rated temperature control 3/5, saying it may still trap heat for some.
- Firmness and value are divisive
Amazon owners are split: some find it soft, others not soft enough, and some call it overpriced. AARP notes only one firmness level and a lack of bounce.
- Some owners say it slides
Amazon's summary says some owners report it stays in place, while others say it slides off the bed.
Who should pick which
Pick the Birch Plush Organic Mattress Topper if
Eco-conscious buyers (GOLS, GREENGUARD Gold)
People who feel trapped by memory foam
Back and side sleepers who move around
Skip it if: You want a very plush, soft top; You're on a budget; You sleep very hot
Pick the Saatva Graphite Memory Foam Mattress Topper if
Side and back sleepers on a too-firm bed
Trying it at home (180-night trial)
Organic cotton cover with straps
Skip it if: You want a long warranty; You are a stomach sleeper over 230 lb; You want bounce
We don't list prices — they change daily. Paid links.