(checked 2026-10-10)Small sample: 844 ratings.
The most customizable machine tested, with the crispiest, most uniform waffles four at a time. It is expensive, heavy, carries only a 1-year warranty, and waffles often have to be pried out.
Top complaints
- Waffles get stuck
Wirecutter often had to pry waffles out, leaving misshapen waffles and crumbs; it blames the deep bottom grid. Amazon's summary says some owners find cooked waffles impossible to remove.
- Expensive with a 1-year warranty
Wirecutter calls the 1-year limited warranty not especially generous for such a costly machine; Serious Eats says it's one of the most expensive it tested.
Source: Wirecutter, Serious Eats - Big and heavy
Wirecutter says it weighs 15.3 pounds and a staffer found it too cumbersome for a small kitchen. Amazon owners are mixed on its size.
What owners love
- Crispiest, most uniform waffles
Wirecutter says it cooks unfailingly uniformly and reached a crispiness its other picks couldn't. Amazon owners praise crispness and waffle quality.
- Most customizable controls
12 browning levels, a waffle-type dial, an 'A Bit More' button, and a countdown timer with a loud beep (Wirecutter, Serious Eats).
Source: Wirecutter, Serious Eats - Overflow moat and sturdy build
A built-in moat catches errant batter and is easy to clean; the stainless housing stays largely cool and the lid locks (Wirecutter). Heavy plates hold heat for quick batches (Serious Eats).
Source: Wirecutter, Serious Eats
- You hate prying out stuck waffles
- You have a small kitchen (15 lb)
- You want removable plates or a long warranty
- Big families and brunch hosts
- Fine-tuning browning (12 levels)
- A countdown timer and loud beep
Scores (tap for why)
What experts say
- Wirecutter (NYT): Upgrade pick: high marks for consistency, versatility, capacity and speed; waffles often need prying out and the warranty is 1 year.
- Serious Eats: Another excellent smart waffle maker, nearly tied with the All-Clad; plates aren't removable and it's one of the most expensive.