ConsFirst / Wireless earbuds

Apple

Apple AirPods 5 problems & complaints

Is it worth it? The downsides first: what owners report, and who should skip it.

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more

Buying on sale? Check this first: “AirPods 5 come in two versions.” What to check →

#10 of 11
$$Noise-cancellingScore 3.3/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available

Apple's fall 2026 open-fit AirPods. Tom's Guide says they sound far better than the AirPods 4, and both versions now have ANC. The catch is battery life: about 4 hours per charge (5 with the wireless-charging case), and the extras need an iPhone.

Common Apple AirPods 5 problems

  • Very short battery life

    Tom's Guide calls the battery very disappointing: 4 hours per charge with the standard case and 5 hours with the wireless-charging case. Its fitness editor got the low-battery warning after about 3 hours of walking and running. Wirecutter, previewing the launch, also says 4 hours with ANC is shorter than it would like.

  • ANC lets sound through, with a faint hiss

    Tom's Guide could still hear car horns, chatter and its own typing with ANC on, and heard a hissing or fizzing noise when ANC was on with no music playing. It points people who need real silence to the AirPods Pro 3.

  • Few changes and Apple-only extras

    Tom's Guide says there is not a huge change from the AirPods 4 apart from ANC and sound, criticizes the dated Bluetooth 5.3, and notes Live Translation needs an Apple Intelligence iPhone and there is no traditional EQ. Its roundup says Android compatibility still holds them back.

What owners like

  • Much better sound than AirPods 4

    Tom's Guide found every genre rich and detailed, with no tinniness and balanced bass, and calls it a big step up from the AirPods 4.

  • Comfortable, sweat-proof open fit

    Tom's Guide's tester, who has very small ears, wore them for about six hours with no pain. They are rated IP57, and a 22-mile test run showed they mostly stayed put.

  • ANC on both versions, and clear calls

    Unlike the AirPods 4, both AirPods 5 versions include ANC (Tom's Guide, Wirecutter). Tom's Guide calls the call quality near-perfect.

Good for
  • iPhone owners on a budget
  • People who dislike silicone ear tips (open-fit, no seal)
  • Small ears (Tom's Guide's tester wore them 6 hours pain-free)

Scores (tap for why)

  • Sound4.0
    Why 4.0?Rich, detailed and balanced per Tom's Guide, but there is no traditional EQ.
  • Noise cancelling3.0
    Why 3.0?Good for an open fit, but Tom's Guide still heard horns, chatter and typing, plus a faint hiss.
  • Comfort & fit4.0
    Why 4.0?Six hours pain-free for a small-eared tester; they moved only a little on a long run (Tom's Guide).
  • Call quality4.0
    Why 4.0?Near-perfect call quality in Tom's Guide's work-call test (one test only).
  • Battery1.5
    Why 1.5?4 h (standard case) or 5 h (wireless case) per charge, per Tom's Guide and Wirecutter.
  • Durability3.5
    Why 3.5?IP57 (Tom's Guide). No long-term durability data yet.

What experts say

  • Tom's Guide: Reviewed the wireless-charging version: much better than the AirPods 4 and the ideal budget pick for iPhone users, but the battery life is very disappointing. 4.5 stars under 'Also tested' in its earbuds roundup.
  • Wirecutter (NYT): Not yet tested ('What to look forward to'): Apple promises better ANC, EQ and water resistance, but 4-5 hours with ANC is shorter than Wirecutter would like.
Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.

Is the Apple AirPods 5 worth it?

Apple's fall 2026 open-fit AirPods. Tom's Guide says they sound far better than the AirPods 4, and both versions now have ANC. The catch is battery life: about 4 hours per charge (5 with the wireless-charging case), and the extras need an iPhone. It ranks #10 of the 11 wireless earbuds we compared.

The deciding question: is “Very short battery life” a deal-breaker for you? If not, still compare it with higher-ranked wireless earbuds before buying. If it is, look elsewhere — see the alternatives below.

If that catch is a deal-breaker

Highly ranked wireless earbuds whose biggest complaint is a different kind of problem.

Head-to-head

Apple AirPods 5: questions people ask

Is the Apple AirPods 5 worth it?

It ranks #10 of the 11 wireless earbuds we compared. Good for: iPhone owners on a budget · people who dislike silicone ear tips (open-fit, no seal) · small ears (Tom's Guide's tester wore them 6 hours pain-free). Skip it if: you need more than 4-5 hours per charge · you use an Android phone · you want strong noise blocking for flights or loud offices.

What is a good alternative to the Apple AirPods 5?

If “Very short battery life” is a deal-breaker for you, consider the Apple AirPods Pro 3 (#1 in wireless earbuds). Its main complaint is a different one: fit can slip or hurt.

See all 11 wireless earbuds ranked →Or take the 3-question quiz

Common problems with other Apple products (12 more) →