ConsFirst / Electric fireplaces

PuraFlame

PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert: the downsides first

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more

#3 of 8
$$InsertScore 3.9/5
4%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)4,601 ratings (2-star 1% + 1-star 3%).

Both Good Housekeeping and Bob Vila name it the most realistic: a brick-lined firebox, resin logs, glowing embers and crackling sounds that slide into an existing fireplace. Its 400 sq ft heat is limited, though, and some owners report trouble installing it.

Top complaints

  • Limited heating range

    Good Housekeeping's con is a limited heating range compared with larger models (rated to about 400 sq ft), and Bob Vila says it is not a primary heat source. On Amazon, heat output is 394 positive to 110 negative.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, Bob Vila, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Installation difficulties for some

    Bob Vila's con is that some users report installation difficulties. Good Housekeeping, by contrast, says you just slide it into the opening and plug it in.

    Source: Bob Vila, Good Housekeeping
  • Noise, remote and flame settings draw some complaints

    These are minority complaints on Amazon: noise (67 negative of 278), remote (38 of 128) and flame settings (19 of 75), though most owners praise the quiet blower.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say)

What owners love

Good for
  • Reviving an unused wood-burning fireplace
  • The most traditional, realistic fire look
  • Crackling sound effects

Scores (tap for why)

  • Flame realism5.0
    Why 5.0?Named most realistic by both Good Housekeeping and Bob Vila; Amazon realism is strongly positive.
    Source: Good Housekeeping, Bob Vila, Amazon.com product page
  • Heat output3.0
    Why 3.0?750/1,500 W, about 400 sq ft; limited range (Good Housekeeping) and not a primary heat source (Bob Vila).
    Source: Good Housekeeping, Bob Vila
  • Quietness3.5
    Why 3.5?Amazon owners mostly praise the quiet blower (211 positive, 67 negative).
    Source: Amazon.com product page
  • Easy install4.0
    Why 4.0?Slide into an existing opening and plug in (Good Housekeeping), though Bob Vila notes some installation difficulties.
    Source: Good Housekeeping, Bob Vila

What experts say

  • Good Housekeeping: Most realistic (updated Feb 2026): incredibly realistic flames and log set, adjustable settings and easy to slide in. The con is limited heating range.
  • Bob Vila: Most realistic (updated Feb 2025): classic design, crackling sounds and three flame effects. The con is that some users report installation difficulties.
Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.

If that catch is a deal-breaker

Highly ranked electric fireplaces whose biggest complaint is something else.

#1 in electric fireplacesDuraflame 3D Infrared Electric Fireplace Stove

This is the top pick in the most roundups: best overall at Good Housekeeping and in both of The Spruce's guides, which tested it four times. It has realistic flames and strong infrared heat, and you only attach four legs to set it up. But the front grill gets hot and the settings are hidden behind the door. On Amazon, more owners complain about the temperature control than praise it.

Its catch: front grill gets hot#2 in electric fireplacesModern Ember Highmark 60" Smart Linear Electric Fireplace

The Spruce's premium wall-mount and smart pick: a big 60-inch unit that impressed its tester with heat in a 350 sq ft basement, with realistic flames, quiet running and good app controls. But it costs about $1,000 more than The Spruce's other wall-mount pick, setup took about 2 hours, the icon-only remote is confusing, and there is little Amazon owner data.

Its catch: confusing remote#4 in electric fireplacesReal Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel

This mantel unit looks like a built-in fireplace, and The Spruce rates it its most realistic. Its tester's unit still worked like new after two years. But it is big, assembly took two people about an hour and The Spruce called it tricky, the mantel can't hold a TV, and the Amazon rating sample is small.

Its catch: assembly takes two people and can be tricky

Head-to-head

See all 8 electric fireplaces ranked →