ConsFirst / Electric fireplaces / Compare
PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert vs Real Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel
Which one has the downsides you can live with?
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more
The short answer
PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert ranks higher (#3 vs #4 of 8) and scores better on flame realism, easy install. Real Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel wins on heat output, quietness.
The biggest complaint about the PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert is limited heating range; for the Real Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel it's assembly takes two people and can be tricky. Pick the one whose catch bothers you less.
Side by side
| PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert | Real Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel | |
|---|---|---|
| Rank in electric fireplaces | #3 | #4 |
| Price tier | $$ | $$ |
| Type | Insert | Freestanding |
| Amazon 1–2★ share | 4% | 2% |
| Overall score | 3.9 | 3.7 |
| Flame realism | 5.0 | 4.5 |
| Heat output | 3.0 | 3.5 |
| Quietness | 3.5 | 4.0 |
| Easy install | 4.0 | 2.5 |
| Durability | — | 4.0 |
Price tiers: $ under $200 · $$ $200–600 · $$$ over $600. Highlighted = clearly better (a score gap of 0.3 or more, or a 1–2★ share at least 3 points lower). Scores are explained, with sources, on each product's page.
Top complaints
PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert
- Limited heating range
Good Housekeeping's con is a limited heating range compared with larger models (rated to about 400 sq ft), and Bob Vila says it is not a primary heat source. On Amazon, heat output is 394 positive to 110 negative.
- Installation difficulties for some
Bob Vila's con is that some users report installation difficulties. Good Housekeeping, by contrast, says you just slide it into the opening and plug it in.
Source: Bob Vila, Good Housekeeping - Noise, remote and flame settings draw some complaints
These are minority complaints on Amazon: noise (67 negative of 278), remote (38 of 128) and flame settings (19 of 75), though most owners praise the quiet blower.
Real Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel
- Assembly takes two people and can be tricky
The Spruce says it took two people just under an hour, and getting the top of the cabinet onto the base needed loosened screws. Its methodology notes say one Real Flame unit took two people more than two hours. Good Housekeeping's con is that assembly is required. Amazon owners, by contrast, mostly call it easy to assemble.
- Large, and the mantel won't hold a TV
The Spruce lists 'doesn't support a TV' as its con (the mantel holds about 31 lb) and says it takes up a lot of space, so it isn't the best for compact rooms.
- One fan speed, beeps, unclear overheat shutoff
The Spruce's heater guide says there is only one fan speed, it beeps when you change settings, and it has no overheat shutoff feature, just a timer of up to nine hours. Good Housekeeping's spec box lists automatic heat shut-off as 'Yes'.
Who should pick which
Pick the PuraFlame Western 33" Electric Fireplace Insert if
Reviving an unused wood-burning fireplace
The most traditional, realistic fire look
Crackling sound effects
Skip it if: You need it as a main heat source; You have no existing fireplace opening; You dislike fan noise
Pick the Real Flame Silverton 48" Electric Fireplace with Mantel if
A traditional mantel look without a chimney
Displaying decor on the mantel
Year-round flames without heat
Skip it if: You want to put a TV on it; Your room is small; You want a one-person, no-assembly setup
We don't list prices — they change daily. Paid links.