ConsFirst / Foot massagers

Foot massagers: the downsides, first

Heat is the most common letdown: six of the eight foot massagers we compared draw complaints that the heat is weak, faint or missing. Pressure that's too strong or too weak, and units that stop working, come up too. Here are the most popular foot massagers in the US, with their downsides first.

8 models compared11 sources readUpdated October 2026

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more

Check with a professional first if this applies to you

Podiatrists quoted by CNN Underscored say people with severe neuropathy, open wounds, active infections, blood clots or significant vascular disease should wait until a professional clears them, and suggest starting at the lowest setting.

Source: CNN Underscored (best foot massagers)

If you just want an answer

Best overallMiko Shiatsu Foot Massager

The Strategist's pick for remote control and a perennial reader favorite, with five pressure settings and two wireless remotes. It has the lowest 1–2★ share here (about 6% of 17,000+ Amazon ratings); the main gripe is heat that some owners find lacking.

Watch out: heat could be betterBest valueNekteck Foot Massager With Heat (open roller)

A cheap, slim open-top roller with very warm infrared heat (145°F in Good Housekeeping's lab) and one-button controls. With no air compression the massage is gentle; CNN found it too weak unless you lean into it, and it has no timer or auto shut-off.

Watch out: massage too weak without leaning inBest performanceNekteck Heated Shiatsu Foot Massager

CNN Underscored's best foot massager: it beat machines costing three times as much, and a tester with plantar fasciitis got real relief. The build feels almost flimsy, the heat is mild and there's no remote; the standard size suits feet up to about men's 11.

Watch out: heat is weak or missing for someAlso greatSharper Image Shiatsu Foot Massager

Good Housekeeping's pick for heat: it reached 122°F, one of the hottest in its lab, and has three quick presets and a timer. Its air compression was weaker than other picks, it's bulky and heavy, and Amazon owners report units that stop heating or working.

Watch out: bulky and heavy

What foot massager owners complain about most

  1. Weak or missing heat. Heat that barely registers or fails comes up for six of the eight models.
  2. Pressure that doesn't fit. Nodes that hurt, pressure that's too weak, or a poor fit for small feet or the inner arch come up for several models.
  3. Units that stop working. Massagers that quit or feel flimsy are reported for four models.
  4. Timers and settings. Missing or fixed timers, a single heat level and few settings bother some owners.
  5. Bulky or pricey. Foot-and-calf and larger models are bulky to store, and some cost a lot at full price.

All 8 foot massagers, ranked

Ranked by test scores, minus how common and serious the complaints are. How we rank

#1
Miko

Miko Shiatsu Foot Massager

$$Foot onlyScore 3.8/5
6%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)The same 17,167-rating histogram also appears on Miko listing B01H5QZ5X8, so ratings are pooled across listings.

The Strategist's pick for remote control and a perennial reader favorite, with five pressure settings and two wireless remotes. It has the lowest 1–2★ share here (about 6% of 17,000+ Amazon ratings); the main gripe is heat that some owners find lacking.

Top complaints

  • Heat could be better

    Amazon's review summary says the heat gets mixed reviews; some owners find it a nice addition, others say it could be better.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Fixed 15-minute timer

    The Strategist notes a 15-minute timer turns the machine off automatically once the massage ends.

    Source: The Strategist (New York Magazine)

What owners love

Good for
  • Controlling the massage from the couch (two remotes)
  • Fine-tuning pressure (five levels)
  • Gifting: a Strategist reader favorite

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • The Strategist (New York Magazine): Best with a remote (updated 2025-09-25): a perennial reader favorite with five pressure settings, multiple techniques and two wireless remotes.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#2
Nekteck

Nekteck Heated Shiatsu Foot Massager

$$Foot onlyScore 3.6/5
11%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)The listing appears to pool sizes (reviews are tagged Size: Regular).

CNN Underscored's best foot massager: it beat machines costing three times as much, and a tester with plantar fasciitis got real relief. The build feels almost flimsy, the heat is mild and there's no remote; the standard size suits feet up to about men's 11.

Top complaints

  • Heat is weak or missing for some

    CNN's tester said the heater could have been stronger. Amazon's review summary says heat gets mixed feedback, with some owners calling it non-existent.

    Source: CNN Underscored, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Light, almost flimsy build

    CNN's tester said it is so lightweight it almost feels flimsy, though it was still going strong after nine months of weekly use.

    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Nodes can hurt; pressure too strong for some

    Amazon's summary says several owners mention the massage balls hurt the bottom of their feet. The same summary describes the massage as not too rough for others.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say)

What owners love

  • Best massage in CNN's 12-machine test

    CNN's tester felt it got every inch from toe to heel without being painful, and it outperformed Renpho's $300 model. Amazon owners call it effective and relaxing for tired, sore feet.

    Source: CNN Underscored, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Very easy to use

    Three modes (kneading and rolling, air pressure, combo) plus a heat toggle; CNN's tester was using it in under a minute without the manual.

    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Compact, with washable covers and a big-foot version

    CNN says the compact frame makes storage easy, the foot covers are washable, and a larger model fits men's 11.5 and up. It has a one-year warranty.

    Source: CNN Underscored
Good for
  • A full toe-to-heel massage without spending premium money
  • People who want simple controls they can use without the manual
  • Large feet, if you buy the separate large version

Scores (tap for why)

  • Intensity & coverage4.5
    Why 4.5?CNN's top-scoring massage, covering toe to heel; some Amazon owners find the nodes hurt.
    Source: CNN Underscored, Amazon.com product page
  • Fit for foot sizes3.5
    Why 3.5?Standard model suits up to about men's 11; a separate large model covers men's 11.5 and up (CNN).
    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Heat2.5
    Why 2.5?CNN's tester wanted stronger heat; Amazon owners are mixed, some say it's non-existent.
    Source: CNN Underscored, Amazon.com product page
  • Controls & noise4.0
    Why 4.0?Very simple panel, usable in under a minute (CNN), but no remote on the standard model.
    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Durability3.5
    Why 3.5?Feels almost flimsy, but held up through nine months of weekly use in CNN's long-term test; one-year warranty.
    Source: CNN Underscored

What experts say

  • CNN Underscored: Best foot massager (updated 2026-09-24). Top massage quality and low price; cons are a near-flimsy feel, mild heat and no remote.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#3
Sharper Image

Sharper Image Shiatsu Foot Massager

$$Foot onlyScore 3.5/5
12%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Small sample: 276 ratings. Good Housekeeping links a Walmart listing; this Amazon listing matches its specs (three modes, men's 12) but we could not confirm it is the identical unit.

Good Housekeeping's pick for heat: it reached 122°F, one of the hottest in its lab, and has three quick presets and a timer. Its air compression was weaker than other picks, it's bulky and heavy, and Amazon owners report units that stop heating or working.

Top complaints

  • Bulky and heavy

    Good Housekeeping says it is larger, bulkier and heavier than the other models it tested.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Weaker compression

    Good Housekeeping found its air compression weaker than its other picks in lab tests.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Heat and durability failures

    Amazon's review summary says several owners report it doesn't heat up and stops working after about six months; opinions on value are split.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say)

What owners love

  • Hottest heat among GH picks

    Reached 122°F in Good Housekeeping's lab, one of the highest temperatures it measured, though you need bare feet to really feel it.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Quick presets and a timer

    Three modes for light, medium or high strength and a 15-, 20- or 30-minute timer (Good Housekeeping).

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Feels like hands

    Good Housekeeping's pros liked its kneading. Amazon owners say it works deep into the feet and feels like someone's hands.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
Good for
  • Cold feet and people who want real warmth
  • Simple light/medium/high presets
  • Feet up to men's 12

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Good Housekeeping: Best with heat (published 2025-10-31): one of the hottest in tests at 122°F, sleek with three presets. Bulkier, and compression is weaker than other picks.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
16%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)

CNN Underscored's runner-up, with a just-right mix of compression, heat and kneading plus a remote and timer. CNN says it's worth it only on sale, and it has the highest 1–2★ share here (16%), with Amazon owners reporting units that quit within a year.

Top complaints

  • Units that stop working

    Amazon's review summary says durability is a concern, with multiple owners reporting it stopped functioning within a year; some call it a waste of money.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Heat can be faint

    Amazon's summary says heat gets mixed feedback; some owners say it is almost non-existent. CNN's tester, by contrast, liked the amount of heat.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say), CNN Underscored
  • Pricey at full price

    CNN says the extras aren't worth it at the full $180 list price, about twice its top pick.

    Source: CNN Underscored

What owners love

  • Just-right massage

    CNN's tester said it used just the right amount of compression, heat and kneading without pain, and her feet felt looser afterward. Amazon owners like the compression-plus-massage combo.

    Source: CNN Underscored, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Remote, timer and adjustable intensity

    CNN notes a timer and adjustable kneading and air compression, all controllable by remote.

    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Close second in testing

    CNN says it was the only model that came close to its top pick, scoring one point lower.

    Source: CNN Underscored
Good for
  • Adjusting kneading and air intensity by remote
  • A relaxing rather than punishing massage
  • Buying on sale (around $100, per CNN)

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • CNN Underscored: Runner-up (updated 2026-09-24): relaxing, just-right massage and more features than the winner, but wait for a sale.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#5
Renpho

Renpho Shiatsu Foot Massager (with remote)

$$Foot onlyScore 3.4/5
14%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)

Good Housekeeping's best overall: strong kneading and compression, a remote and a fit that worked for both large and small feet in its lab. CNN found it only adequate and the heat mild, and Amazon owners raise reliability concerns.

Top complaints

  • Heat underwhelms

    Good Housekeeping measured less than the claimed 131°F, with heat focused mainly on the toes. CNN found the heat too mild even on high, and Amazon's summary says heat gets mixed feedback.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, CNN Underscored, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Units that stop working

    Amazon's review summary says reliability is a concern because the device stops working, and comfort is mixed, with some owners finding it painful.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Misses the inner arch; weak remote

    CNN says the nodes stay mostly stationary and neglected the inside of the arch (a problem it saw on all machines), and the remote signal was so weak the tester had to bend over to use it.

    Source: CNN Underscored

What owners love

  • Strong kneading and compression

    Good Housekeeping calls the kneading impressive and the compression powerful, with three intensity levels each. Amazon owners praise the adjustability and say the rollers feel great.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Fits large and small feet

    It fit both larger and smaller feet in Good Housekeeping's lab; the max listed size is men's 12.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Easy setup, remote and washable liner

    Good Housekeeping found it easy to set up and the liner simple to remove for cleaning; it likes the wireless remote. CNN calls setup extremely straightforward and the soft-shell body easy to stow.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, CNN Underscored
Good for
  • Households with different foot sizes (up to men's 12)
  • Adjusting kneading, air and heat separately
  • Easy cleaning with a removable liner

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Good Housekeeping: Best overall (published 2025-10-31): impressive kneading, powerful compression and a remote. Heat could be better.
  • CNN Underscored: Good but not great (updated 2026-09-24): adequate, customizable massage, but mild heat, a weak remote and better options at its list price.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#6
Comfier

Comfier Shiatsu Foot Massager

$$Foot onlyScore 3.4/5
12%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)

Good Housekeeping's best value, with the strongest air compression in its lab and a compact body. There's only one heat level and no timer, and the extra vibration mode was noisy.

Top complaints

  • One heat level, which may barely register

    Good Housekeeping notes there's only one heat setting. Amazon's summary says heat gets mixed feedback, with some owners saying it is non-existent.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • No timer

    There's no timer; Good Housekeeping's engineer says it stops on its own after about 15 minutes.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Noisy vibration mode

    Good Housekeeping's reviewer didn't enjoy the vibration setting and found it noisy.

    Source: Good Housekeeping

What owners love

  • Strongest compression tested

    Its air compression was the most powerful of Good Housekeeping's picks in lab tests. Amazon owners like the compression and call it worth the money.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
  • Compact and portable

    Good Housekeeping likes that it can be stored under a desk or couch.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Comfortable across foot sizes

    It was comfortable for testers wearing men's 11 and women's 7; Good Housekeeping lists a max size of 13. The liner is washable.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
Good for
  • People who like a firm squeeze
  • Storing under a desk or couch
  • Feet up to size 13

Scores (tap for why)

  • Intensity & coverage4.5
    Why 4.5?Most powerful air compression in GH's lab, plus three kneading levels and vibration.
    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Fit for foot sizes4.0
    Why 4.0?Comfortable for men's 11 and women's 7 testers; max size 13 (GH).
    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Heat2.0
    Why 2.0?Only one heat level (GH); some Amazon owners say the heat is non-existent.
    Source: Good Housekeeping, Amazon.com product page
  • Controls & noise3.0
    Why 3.0?Three levels each for kneading, compression and vibration, but no timer and a noisy vibration mode (GH).
    Source: Good Housekeeping

What experts say

  • Good Housekeeping: Best value (published 2025-10-31): most powerful compression in lab tests and adds vibration. Only one heat setting and no timer.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#7
Nekteck

Nekteck Foot Massager With Heat (open roller)

$Foot onlyScore 3.1/5
8%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)

A cheap, slim open-top roller with very warm infrared heat (145°F in Good Housekeeping's lab) and one-button controls. With no air compression the massage is gentle; CNN found it too weak unless you lean into it, and it has no timer or auto shut-off.

Top complaints

  • Massage too weak without leaning in

    CNN says that without air pressure or body weight, not much happened; you have to lean forward for a deeper massage. Good Housekeeping notes the open design lacks the intensity of enclosed massagers.

    Source: CNN Underscored, Good Housekeeping
  • No timer or auto shut-off

    Good Housekeeping's engineer warns you'll need to remember to turn it off, since it has no timer or automatic shut-off.

    Source: Good Housekeeping
  • Few settings; full-body claim is a stretch

    Strength isn't adjustable and the only setting is heat on/off (GH). CNN found it unergonomic on the back and weak on calves and hamstrings, while Good Housekeeping liked it on calves and hamstrings.

    Source: Good Housekeeping, CNN Underscored

What owners love

Good for
  • People who want a light touch plus lots of warmth
  • Sliding under a couch
  • Budget buyers (about $50)

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Good Housekeeping: Best versatile (published 2025-10-31): gentle, relaxing kneading and strong heat; limited settings, no adjustable strength, no timer.
  • CNN Underscored: Tested, not recommended (updated 2026-09-24): great heat and simple, but the massage was too weak without leaning in.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#8
Renpho

Renpho Shiatsu Calf & Foot Massager Pro 2

$$$Foot & calfScore 3.5/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available

A highly adjustable 20-pound machine that also does calves and forearms; CNN's tester said it worked well on tired, sore feet and calves. It's expensive, bulky, hard to store and awkward for very small feet, and the tester wouldn't buy it.

Top complaints

  • Bulky and hard to store

    CNN calls it a 20-pound eyesore that is hard to store without closet space.

    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Awkward for small feet

    CNN's tester, who has very small feet, found it awkward to use.

    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Expensive; strong on arms

    CNN calls the price eye-popping and its tester wouldn't buy it herself. She also said it may be too strong for older, thinner skin on the arms.

    Source: CNN Underscored

What owners love

  • Works feet and calves

    CNN's tester said it performed well on tired, sore feet and calves and might suit workout recovery.

    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Highly customizable

    CNN lists four air modes, adjustable intensity and a built-in timer. Renpho lists 3 knead and 4 pressure levels, heat and a remote.

    Source: CNN Underscored, Renpho product page
Good for
  • Sore calves as well as feet
  • Post-workout recovery
  • Lots of settings (knead and pressure levels, timer, remote)

Scores (tap for why)

  • Intensity & coverage4.0
    Why 4.0?Performed well on feet and calves; may be too strong for thin skin on arms (CNN).
    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Fit for foot sizes2.5
    Why 2.5?Awkward for CNN's tester with very small feet.
    Source: CNN Underscored
  • Controls & noise4.0
    Why 4.0?Four air modes, adjustable intensity, timer (CNN) and a remote (Renpho).
    Source: CNN Underscored, Renpho product page

What experts say

  • CNN Underscored: Tested, not recommended over the winner (updated 2026-09-24): relaxing on feet and calves, but pricey, 20 lb, hard to store and awkward for small feet.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonMaker's pageWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.

Questions people ask

What do foot massager owners complain about most?

Across the 8 popular foot massagers we compared, the complaints that came up most were: weak or missing heat; pressure that doesn't fit; units that stop working; timers and settings; bulky or pricey.

What is the best foot massager overall?

Our top pick is the Miko Shiatsu Foot Massager. The Strategist's pick for remote control and a perennial reader favorite, with five pressure settings and two wireless remotes. It has the lowest 1–2★ share here (about 6% of 17,000+ Amazon ratings); the main gripe is heat that some owners find lacking. Its most common complaint: heat could be better.

What is the best budget foot massager?

The Nekteck Foot Massager With Heat (open roller) is our pick in the lowest price tier. A cheap, slim open-top roller with very warm infrared heat (145°F in Good Housekeeping's lab) and one-button controls. With no air compression the massage is gentle; CNN found it too weak unless you lean into it, and it has no timer or auto shut-off.

Which foot massager has the fewest 1–2 star ratings on Amazon?

Among the models whose Amazon rating breakdown we could check reliably, the Nekteck Foot Massager With Heat (open roller) had the lowest share of 1–2 star ratings (8%), and the Mountrax Heated Foot Massager for Deep-Tissue Relief the highest (16%), as of October 10, 2026.

How does ConsFirst rank foot massagers?

We summarize owner complaints from retailer reviews and the results of independent expert tests, score each model on intensity & coverage, fit for foot sizes, heat, controls & noise, durability, and rank by those scores minus how common the complaints are. Every claim links to its source.

Compare the top picks

Side by side

ModelPrice1–2★ shareScore#1 complaint
Miko Shiatsu Foot Massager$$6%3.8Heat could be better
Nekteck Heated Shiatsu Foot Massager$$11%3.6Heat is weak or missing for some
Sharper Image Shiatsu Foot Massager$$12%3.5Bulky and heavy
Mountrax Heated Foot Massager for Deep-Tissue Relief$$16%3.5Units that stop working
Renpho Shiatsu Foot Massager (with remote)$$14%3.4Heat underwhelms
Comfier Shiatsu Foot Massager$$12%3.4One heat level, which may barely register
Nekteck Foot Massager With Heat (open roller)$8%3.1Massage too weak without leaning in
Renpho Shiatsu Calf & Foot Massager Pro 2$$$—3.5Bulky and hard to store

Price tiers: $ under $80 · $$ $80–200 · $$$ over $200 (typical list price, not a live price).

More in personal care

Electric toothbrushes8 models comparedMost common gripe: dying or not charging within a yearWater flossers8 models comparedMost common gripe: stops charging or breaks within a yearHair dryers8 models comparedMost common gripe: early failuresHair straighteners8 models comparedMost common gripe: paying more without better resultsElectric shavers8 models comparedMost common gripe: not as close as a bladeMassage guns8 models comparedMost common gripe: heavy or awkward to holdHair clippers & beard trimmers8 models comparedMost common gripe: units that break earlyMulti-stylers & Airwrap alternatives8 models comparedMost common gripe: units that stop workingBidets & bidet seats8 models comparedMost common gripe: leaks and failuresSmart scales8 models comparedMost common gripe: pairing problems and dead scalesNeck & shoulder massagers8 models comparedMost common gripe: massagers that stop workingAt-home IPL hair removal8 models comparedMost common gripe: results vary a lotMassage chairs8 models comparedMost common gripe: too intense or too hard