ConsFirst / Electric shavers

Electric shavers: the downsides, first

Electric shavers trade closeness for comfort, and the running cost of replacement heads catches many buyers out. Here are the most popular men's shavers in the US, with their downsides first.

8 models compared24 sources readUpdated October 2026

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more

If you just want an answer

What electric shaver owners complain about most

  1. Not as close as a blade. Budget shavers and trimmers often take many passes and still miss dense or flat-lying hair.
  2. Skin irritation. Redness and irritation, especially on the neck, come up for several models — and what's gentle for one person isn't for another.
  3. Replacement heads add up. Heads and blades are a real running cost; Wirecutter puts Braun Series 8/9 heads at about $70 every 18 months.
  4. Premium models, small gains. Owners and testers question whether top-end shavers shave noticeably closer than mid-range ones.
  5. Noise and flimsy parts. Loud motors, foils that pop out and bulky cleaning stations are frequent gripes.

All 8 electric shavers, ranked

Ranked by test scores, minus how common and serious the complaints are. How we rank

#1
Braun

Braun Series 9 PRO+ Electric Shaver

$$$FoilScore 4.3/5
9%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
1,882 ratings (6% 1-star, 3% 2-star). The listing pools 4-piece and 6-piece sets. Walmart's Series 9 Pro 9477cc listing (595 ratings) shows 17% at 1-2 stars.

The fastest, most forgiving shaver in this group, picked by Wirecutter, CNN and ShaverCheck. It is expensive to buy, and replacement heads cost about $70. Some owners upgrading from older Braun models say it doesn't shave any closer.

Top complaints

  • Expensive to buy and to maintain

    Wirecutter says a replacement head costs about $70 and should be swapped every 18 months, and that for daily shavers the gain over the Series 8 isn't worth the extra cost. ShaverCheck lists price as a con and says the new 96M head costs slightly more than older Series 9 heads. Amazon's review summary says some owners find it expensive to maintain.

  • Loud, bulky cleaning station and a weak trimmer

    CNN Underscored says the loud cleaning cycle was the only real drawback. Wirecutter found the station and charging case take a lot of counter space, the pop-up trimmer doesn't get as close as a standalone trimmer, and the head pivots only vertically. ShaverCheck calls the trimmer mediocre and the shaver itself noisy.

  • Some owners find it no closer than older models

    Walmart's lowest-rated reviews of the Series 9 Pro 9477cc say an older Series 7 shaved closer, shaving took longer than with a manual razor, and the trimmer hardly trims. Amazon's summary for the PRO+ says skin-irritation feedback is mixed.

What owners love

  • Fastest shave, no irritation

    CNN Underscored shaved a three-day beard in about 1 minute 30 seconds, versus nearly 3 minutes with the Panasonic Arc5, with zero irritation. Wirecutter found it closer and more comfortable than the Series 8 and able to cut a seven-day beard without snags.

  • Easy, automatic cleaning

    CNN liked the release buttons that pop the head off and the sealed cleaning cartridge, which is less messy than Panasonic's dock. Amazon owners praise the easy upkeep with the included station.

  • Good for sensitive skin, long warranty

    ShaverCheck reports no bumps, irritation or nicks even on the neck, and up to 5 years of warranty with registration. Amazon owners describe a very close, smooth shave in a couple of minutes.

Good for
  • Thick beards or shaving every few days
  • Sensitive skin that still wants a fast shave
  • Hands-off cleaning with a dock

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Wirecutter (NYT): Upgrade pick (updated 2026-06-08), tested as the Series 9 Pro 9477cc: the most velvety shave of the group and better for thick, heavy growth, but not worth the extra cost for daily shavers.
  • CNN Underscored: Best professional-level razor (Series 9 Pro): the closest, most comfortable and speediest shave it tested, with a loud cleaning cycle as the only real drawback.
  • ShaverCheck: Best all-rounder if you have the budget (PRO+, guide updated 2026-08-20); 4.5/5 in its PRO+ review, but not quite the closest razor at this price.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
10%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
Small sample: 765 ratings (7% 1-star, 3% 2-star). This is the Prestige Ultra listing; separate Amazon listings for the non-Ultra i9000 Prestige had only about 90-130 ratings each.

The best rotary shaver according to Wirecutter and ShaverCheck: it glides easily over the jaw and neck and handles a few days' growth. Foil shavers still cut closer. You pay extra for app and sensor features, and owners report mixed results on irritation and battery.

Top complaints

  • Pricey for small gains

    ShaverCheck lists the price and only incremental gains over earlier Philips models as cons. Wirecutter says you're paying for frivolous extras such as a light-up pressure sensor and app coaching. Amazon's summary says some owners find it disappointing for such an expensive model.

  • Irritation and battery are hit-or-miss

    ShaverCheck, whose reviewer has sensitive skin, had occasional stinging and redness and says foil shavers usually shave closer. Amazon's summary says some owners find it excellent for sensitive skin while others report lots of irritation, and some complain of fast battery drain.

  • App sign-up, no USB-C, no wall charger

    Wirecutter notes the GroomTribe app requires registering an email address. ShaverCheck says some features are app-only and the shaver uses a Philips-to-USB-A cable with no USB-C and no charger included.

What owners love

Good for
  • Rotary fans
  • Shaving every few days
  • Easy rinsing and a long warranty

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Wirecutter (NYT): Best rotary (updated 2026-06-08): a close, smooth cut, a narrow and grippy body, and easy cleaning. The app and pressure-light extras are frivolous but don't hurt performance.
  • ShaverCheck: 4/5 for the Prestige Ultra (updated 2025-05-21); its 2026 guide calls it the best rotary for shaving less often. It says comfort is about as good as a rotary gets, but price and incremental gains count against it.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#3
Braun

Braun Series 8 Electric Shaver

$$$FoilScore 4.1/5
12%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
Small sample: 959 ratings (7% 1-star, 5% 2-star) on the 8517s listing, which also offers 5- and 6-piece sets.

Wirecutter's top pick: a comfortable, quick foil shaver that gets close to the Series 9 for less money. Panasonic's Arc5 shaves closer on coarse beards, and replacement heads cost about $70.

Top complaints

  • Pricey replacement heads

    Wirecutter says the foils should be replaced every 18 months and a new head runs about $70. ShaverCheck lists the pricey head as a con, though it costs less than a Series 9 cassette.

  • Not the closest on coarse beards

    ShaverCheck found the neck and chin sometimes left slightly rough patches with coarse, dense hair and says Panasonic's Arc 4 and Arc 5 shave closer. Amazon's review summary says opinions on its functionality and value are mixed.

  • Head only pivots one way; weak trimmer; bulky extras

    Wirecutter notes the head pivots only vertically, the built-in trimmer is no match for a standalone one, and the cc version's cleaning station and nearly 10-inch charging case take up space. ShaverCheck calls the slide-out trimmer mediocre and says the shaver is pretty loud; Amazon's summary calls noise feedback mixed.

What owners love

Good for
  • Daily shavers who want Braun comfort for less
  • Sensitive skin
  • Long battery life

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Wirecutter (NYT): Top pick (updated 2026-06-08): a close, clean, comfortable shave at about 40 dB. The 8517s is the same razor without the cleaning station and charging case and costs about $100 less.
  • ShaverCheck: 4.5/5 (updated 2026-07-21, tested on the 8370cc; it says all Series 8 generations shave the same). Very comfortable with adequately close shaves, but not quite as good as the old Series 7.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#4
Panasonic

Panasonic ARC5 Electric Shaver

$$FoilScore 3.7/5
9%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
2,932 ratings (6% 1-star, 3% 2-star) on the ES-LV97-K listing, which offers several configurations that may share reviews.

CNN's top pick and one of the closest-shaving razors you can buy. It is harsher on sensitive skin than Braun, and its battery life is only average. Testers also found its cleaning dock messier than Braun's.

Top complaints

  • Harsher on sensitive skin

    ShaverCheck saw pinching and stinging on the neck when moving fast and mild redness, says Braun's Series 8 or 9 is gentler, and doesn't recommend it for very sensitive skin. Amazon's summary says some owners report red, burning or irritated skin.

  • Slower, struggles with long flat-lying hair

    ShaverCheck says it struggles with long, flat-lying hair, a long-standing Panasonic issue. Wirecutter found neither Arc5 version shaved as quickly or closely as its top Braun pick, and CNN's three-day beard took nearly 3 minutes versus about 1.5 minutes with the Braun Series 9 Pro.

  • Messy dock, pricey parts, average battery

    CNN says the dock uses an open reservoir where you mix detergent and water, so you have to empty it to travel, and it is loud. ShaverCheck says the detergent tray can grow mold and mildew, foils (yearly) and blades (every two years) are pricey, and battery life is okay but behind Braun and Philips. Amazon battery feedback is mixed.

What owners love

Good for
  • The closest possible shave
  • Daily shavers with coarse beards
  • Hand-rinsing with a sonic cleaning mode

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • CNN Underscored: Best electric razor of 14 tested: close, comfortable and user-friendly, though the detergent dock is messier than Braun's.
  • ShaverCheck: 4.5/5, Editor's choice (updated 2026-08-15): one of the closest shavers available, but not ideal for long, flat-lying hair or very sensitive skin, and its parts are pricey.
  • Wirecutter (NYT): Not picked: it tested the ARC5 and the compact ES-PV3A and found neither shaved as quickly or closely as the Braun Series 8.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#5
Philips Norelco

Philips Norelco Shaver 3600 (Series 3000)

$RotaryScore 3.7/5
10%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
3,423 ratings (7% 1-star, 3% 2-star) on the Storm Blue S3243/91 listing. Walmart's Shaver 3600 listing (3,465 ratings) also shows 10%.

ShaverCheck's pick for the best affordable rotary: comfortable, quiet, with long battery life and cheap heads. It isn't very close on the chin or under the nose, and some owners get neck irritation.

Top complaints

What owners love

Good for
  • Rotary shaving on a budget
  • Shaving every few days
  • Long battery life

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • ShaverCheck: 4/5 for the Series 3000 3600/3800/3900 (updated 2024-12-14), which it says all shave identically. Its 2026 guide calls the 3600 the best affordable rotary for most users and notes the Arc 3 or Series 3 shave closer.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
9%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
27,345 ratings (6% 1-star, 3% 2-star); Amazon lists the item model as 3040BLK. Walmart's 3040s listing (1,137 ratings) shows 14% at 1-2 stars.

A gentle, cheap-to-run budget foil shaver that ShaverCheck rates highly for daily shavers. It is not very close and needs extra passes on longer hair. Walmart's lowest-rated reviews are dominated by complaints about the shave.

Top complaints

  • Not very close; takes many passes

    ShaverCheck rates closeness as adequate, says it can miss longer flat-lying hairs and works best with daily shaving. Walmart 1-star reviewers say it needed many passes, didn't shave closely or pulled hair, and Amazon's summary says shaving performance is mixed.

  • Noisy and sometimes underpowered

    ShaverCheck calls it loud, with a raspy buzz and more vibration than Braun's high-end shavers, and found it underpowered at times. It also comes without a travel case or lubricant.

  • Some break within months

    Amazon's summary says durability is mixed, with some owners reporting it broke after 6 months. A Walmart 1-star review says the foil head separated three times during use.

What owners love

Good for
  • Daily or every-other-day shavers
  • Sensitive skin on a budget
  • Cheap, long-lasting replacement heads

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • ShaverCheck: 4.5/5, Editor's choice (updated 2026-07-29); its 2026 guide calls it the best shaver for budget-conscious buyers. Gentle and durable, but noisy and only adequately close.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#7
Philips Norelco

Philips Norelco OneBlade 360 Face Hybrid Trimmer and Shaver

$Hybrid trimmerScore 3.4/5
11%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)
14,183 ratings (8% 1-star, 3% 2-star). Walmart's QP2724/70 listing (4,679 ratings) shows 10%.

A cheap, very gentle tool for trimming, edging and shaving stubble. It does not give a close shave, and testers still had stubble after using it. Its blades cost nearly as much as the device and wear out in about 4 months.

Top complaints

  • Not a close shave

    Wirecutter's testers still had pronounced stubble after using it. CNN found it slightly less close than multi-blade razors and better for two- to three-day shaves. TechRadar says it doesn't deliver the closest shave, and Amazon's summary says owners disagree on closeness compared with manual razors.

  • Blades are a running cost

    TechRadar says replacement heads can cost nearly as much as the shaver. Philips says a blade lasts about four months on average, and TechRadar has seen reports of faster dulling. A Walmart 1-star reviewer says a blade wore out after one use.

  • Heads break; battery and charger gripes

    Amazon's summary flags durability, with heads falling apart, and mixed battery feedback, including units that won't hold a charge. Walmart 1-star reviewers say it broke on the third use and one arrived without its proprietary charger. TechRadar notes there is no USB-C charging.

What owners love

  • Extremely gentle

    TechRadar found razor burn wasn't an issue and calls it a strong choice for very sensitive skin. Amazon owners say it is easy on the skin.

  • Versatile and precise

    CNN liked the small head that lets you see what you're shaving and found it great for clearing multi-week growth. Wirecutter's trimmer testers found it great for detail work on beards and mustaches.

  • Waterproof and easy to clean

    TechRadar lists waterproofing, easy cleaning and solid build among its pros, with about 1 hour of battery.

    Source: TechRadar
Good for
  • Keeping a short stubble or styling a beard
  • Very sensitive or razor-burn-prone skin
  • Two- to three-day shaves

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Wirecutter (NYT): Not picked: great for fine-detail beard work, but the shave wasn't close enough, and testers still had pronounced stubble.
  • CNN Underscored: Tested but not picked: one of the most enjoyable razors it used, but the narrow head and less-close shave suit two- to three-day shaves more than daily use.
  • TechRadar: An affordable, gentle jack-of-all-trades that doesn't excel at any one thing; it has no USB-C charging, and replacement heads cost nearly as much as the shaver.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.
#8
Remington

Remington F5-5800 Foil Shaver

$FoilScore 3.2/5
10%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)

The budget pick at both Wirecutter and CNN: a surprisingly close shave for about $56, and it runs corded or cordless. It is rougher on skin, loud and flimsy, and owners report foils that pop out or break.

Top complaints

  • Rougher on skin

    Wirecutter found it more aggressive than its other picks, as if nibbling the skin, with more redness. ShaverCheck doesn't recommend it for very sensitive skin, and a Walmart 1-star reviewer said it felt like it pulled hairs out instead of cutting them.

  • Flimsy build; foils pop out or break

    One Wirecutter tester thought it might fly apart, CNN found the head flimsy with blades that fall out when opened, and ShaverCheck says the foils seem brittle. Walmart 1-star reviewers describe foils popping out during use, a foil breaking after 6 months, and units that stopped charging. Amazon's summary says durability is mixed, with some breaking after 30 days.

  • Loud, bulky, weak on the neck

    Wirecutter measured 45 dB, among the loudest it tested (a partner compared it to a weed whacker), and found the body too bulky to grip comfortably. It also underperforms on the neck. ShaverCheck says it often missed longer, flat-lying hairs and is pretty loud.

What owners love

Good for
  • A close shave on a tight budget
  • Shaving while plugged in when the battery is dead
  • Dry shaving

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Wirecutter (NYT): Budget pick at about $56: a fairly close, even shave and 60 minutes of battery, but more redness, 45 dB of noise and an awkward grip.
  • CNN Underscored: Best budget razor: an impressively clean shave for the money, but it's dry-shave only, feels flimsy and is fiddly to clean.
  • ShaverCheck: 4/5 (updated 2023-04-24); its 2026 guide names it best for a close shave on a budget. It is not ideal for sensitive skin and has a disappointing trimmer.
Full breakdown →Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.

Questions people ask

What do electric shaver owners complain about most?

Across the 8 popular electric shavers we compared, the complaints that came up most were: not as close as a blade; skin irritation; replacement heads add up; premium models, small gains; noise and flimsy parts.

What is the best electric shaver overall?

Our top pick is the Braun Series 9 PRO+ Electric Shaver. The fastest, most forgiving shaver in this group, picked by Wirecutter, CNN and ShaverCheck. It is expensive to buy, and replacement heads cost about $70. Some owners upgrading from older Braun models say it doesn't shave any closer. Its most common complaint: expensive to buy and to maintain.

What is the best budget electric shaver?

The Philips Norelco Shaver 3600 (Series 3000) is our pick in the lowest price tier. ShaverCheck's pick for the best affordable rotary: comfortable, quiet, with long battery life and cheap heads. It isn't very close on the chin or under the nose, and some owners get neck irritation.

How does ConsFirst rank electric shavers?

We summarize owner complaints from retailer reviews and the results of independent expert tests, score each model on closeness, skin comfort, battery, easy cleaning, durability, and rank by those scores minus how common the complaints are. Every claim links to its source.

Compare the top picks

Side by side

ModelPrice1–2★ shareScore#1 complaint
Braun Series 9 PRO+ Electric Shaver$$$9%4.3Expensive to buy and to maintain
Philips Norelco i9000 Prestige / Prestige Ultra Electric Shaver$$$10%4.1Pricey for small gains
Braun Series 8 Electric Shaver$$$12%4.1Pricey replacement heads
Panasonic ARC5 Electric Shaver$$9%3.7Harsher on sensitive skin
Philips Norelco Shaver 3600 (Series 3000)$10%3.7Not very close in dense areas
Braun Series 3 ProSkin 3040s Electric Shaver$9%3.5Not very close; takes many passes
Philips Norelco OneBlade 360 Face Hybrid Trimmer and Shaver$11%3.4Not a close shave
Remington F5-5800 Foil Shaver$10%3.2Rougher on skin

Price tiers: $ under $80 · $$ $80–200 · $$$ over $200 (typical list price, not a live price).

More in personal care