ConsFirst / Mattresses
Mattresses: the downsides, first
Firmness is the gamble: support that feels too soft, too firm or inconsistent comes up for five of the eight mattresses we compared, and weak edges and motion transfer come up for four each. Check the trial and return terms — one top pick charges $99 to return. Here are the most popular mattresses in the US, with their downsides first.
8 models compared18 sources readUpdated October 2026
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more
All 8 mattresses, ranked
Ranked by test scores, minus how common and serious the complaints are. How we rank
#1
Saatva
$$$InnerspringScore 4.4/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available
Tom's Guide's highest-scoring mattress and a top pick at Wirecutter and Sleep Foundation: a coil-on-coil bed with a Euro top that sleeps cool, has very strong edges, and comes with a year-long trial and free white-glove delivery. But it costs about $1,800 or more for a queen, returns cost $99, it's sold only by Saatva, and reviewers disagree on how well it isolates motion.
Top complaints
- $99 to return or exchangeVery common
Saatva gives a 365-night trial, but Tom's Guide lists the $99 exchange and return fee as a con, and Wirecutter and Sleep Foundation say returns carry a $99 charge. After year 2 of the warranty, repairs carry a $149 transportation charge (Sleep Foundation).
- Motion transferVery common
Wirecutter says it doesn't have the best motion isolation, and Sleep Foundation rates motion isolation 6.5/10 and says it doesn't isolate much motion. Tom's Guide disagrees: it scored 4/5 in its lab test, the best of the hybrids it tested.
- Expensive, with weight and feel limitsMentioned often
Tom's Guide says a queen generally costs about $1,839 and notes a 300 lb per person weight limit. Sleep Foundation says fans of close-conforming memory foam won't like its more responsive surface, and its firmer models don't provide great pressure relief.
What owners love
- Sleeps cool
Tom's Guide gave it 5/5 for temperature; it absorbed the least heat of its top five in a thermal-camera test. Sleep Foundation rates temperature control 10/10.
- Best-in-class edge support
Tom's Guide gave the only 5/5 edge-support score it has awarded; testers could lie right up to the edge. Sleep Foundation rates edge support 8.5/10.
- Year-long trial and white-glove delivery
365-night trial, lifetime warranty and free white-glove delivery, which Tom's Guide values at about $175-200.
Skip it if…- You want a deep, hugging memory-foam feel
- You're very sensitive to a partner's movements
- You or your partner weigh over 300 lb
Good for- Hot sleepers who like to lie on top of the bed
- Sitting or sleeping near the edge
- Choosing among three firmness levels
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges5.0
Why 5.0?
Tom's Guide's only 5/5 edge score; Sleep Foundation edge 8.5/10. - Sleeps cool5.0
Why 5.0?
Tom's Guide 5/5 (least heat absorbed); Sleep Foundation temperature 10/10. - Motion isolation3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide 4/5 in its lab test, but Sleep Foundation rates 6.5/10 and Wirecutter says it isn't the best at motion isolation. - Trial & returns4.0
Why 4.0?
365-night trial and lifetime warranty, but returns cost $99. - Durability (sagging)4.5
Why 4.5?
Sleep Foundation durability 8/10; Tom's Guide says it's built to last longer than average, with 13-gauge base coils meant to resist sagging.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide: Best overall (updated 2026-05-23, 4.8/5): pressure relief, cooling and edge support all 5/5; $99 return fee, 600 lb couple limit.
- Wirecutter: Top pick for innerspring, side sleepers and pain (updated 2026-06-23): plush bounce with a cushy top, but not the best motion isolation.
- Sleep Foundation: Best luxury innerspring (updated 2026-09-30, 9.5/10): temperature 10, edge 8.5, durability 8, motion isolation 6.5.
#2
Helix
$$$HybridScore 4.1/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available
Sleep Foundation's best overall and Tom's Guide's best for side sleepers: a pillow-topped hybrid with zoned lumbar coils, strong edges and plenty of hip and shoulder cushioning. But it's one of the priciest beds on these lists, the plush top can make it hard to move around on, and Tom's Guide says hot sleepers should pay for the cooling cover.
Top complaints
- Hard to move around onVery common
Tom's Guide says the plush pillow top limited ease of movement for some testers. Sleep Foundation says this could be an issue for combination sleepers and people with mobility problems.
- Hot sleepers need the cooling upgradeMentioned often
Tom's Guide rated temperature 4/5 but says very hot sleepers should upgrade to the GlacioTex cool-touch cover or CoolForce layer.
- Expensive, with some bounceMentioned often
Tom's Guide calls it 'a bona fide splurge' and the priciest mattress on its list (typically about $1,849-$1,918 for a queen). Motion isolation is mid-pack at 3.5/5, and Tom's Guide lists 'some bounce might be disruptive' as a con.
What owners love
- Cushioning for side sleepers
Tom's Guide scored pressure relief 4.5/5, second only to the Saatva, and says side and back sleepers on its panel found it comfortable.
- Strong edges and durability
Sleep Foundation rates edge support 9.5/10 and durability 8.5/10; Tom's Guide could comfortably sit on the sides (4/5).
- Year-long trial now
Tom's Guide reports that Helix's parent, 3Z Brands, now offers a 365-night trial on all its beds; it ships free with a lifetime warranty.
Skip it if…- You change positions a lot or have mobility issues
- You run very hot and won't pay for the cooling cover
- You're on a mid-range budget
Good for- Side sleepers who want a sink-in feel
- Back sleepers wanting lumbar support
- Couples who sleep near the edge
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges4.5
Why 4.5?
Sleep Foundation edge 9.5/10; Tom's Guide edge 4/5. - Sleeps cool4.0
Why 4.0?
Tom's Guide temperature 4/5 (cooling cover recommended for hot sleepers); Sleep Foundation temperature 8/10. - Motion isolation3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide 3.5/5 (mid-pack); Sleep Foundation 8.5/10. - Trial & returns4.5
Why 4.5?
365-night trial across 3Z brands (Tom's Guide, Oct 2026), with free shipping and returns and a lifetime warranty. - Durability (sagging)4.0
Why 4.0?
Sleep Foundation durability 8.5/10.
What experts say
- Sleep Foundation: Best mattress overall (updated 2026-09-30, 9.7/10): edge 9.5, motion 8.5, temperature 8, durability 8.5.
- Tom's Guide: Best for side sleepers (updated 2026-05-23): pressure relief 4.5, temperature 4, edge 4, motion 3.5; can be hard to move on.
#3
DreamCloud
$$HybridScore 3.8/5
14%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Small sample: 539 ratings (1-star 9%, 2-star 5%); listing is titled 'Firm Feel' and pools sizes.Tom's Guide's best mid-range mattress: a 12-inch hybrid with reinforced edges, decent cooling, a one-year trial and a lifetime warranty for about $649-$699 a queen. But it's too soft for stomach sleepers, you're likely to feel a partner move, and Amazon owners are split on firmness and say the sides collapse for some.
Top complaints
- Firmness and support are hit-or-missVery common
Amazon's summary says firmness and support are mixed, with some finding it softer than expected. Tom's Guide says it's too soft for stomach sleepers, and its reviewer felt hip pressure. Sleep Foundation says it comes in only one firmness that can be too soft for some.
- Edges can sinkMentioned often
Some Amazon owners report no support on the sides and say the sides collapse. Sleep Foundation testers noted sinkage at the edges, though Tom's Guide rated edge support 4/5.
- You'll feel your partner moveMentioned often
Tom's Guide lists 'likely to feel partner's movements' as a con; motion isolation is its weak point at 3.5/5.
What owners love
- Strong value
Tom's Guide calls it the best mattress for under $1,000, regularly $649 for a queen, and scored value 5/5.
- Year-long trial and lifetime warranty
365-night trial; after a 30-night break-in, DreamCloud arranges donation and a full refund (Sleep Foundation). Lifetime limited warranty.
- Neutral temperature and easy to move on
Tom's Guide scored temperature and pressure relief 4/5 and praised its excellent ease of movement, though its reviewer did overheat on it.
Skip it if…- You sleep on your stomach
- You're a light sleeper sharing the bed
- You weigh over 230 lb and want firm support
Good for- Hybrid feel on a mid-range budget
- Side and back sleepers
- Trying a bed for a full year
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide edge 4/5 and Sleep Foundation 7.5/10, but testers and some Amazon owners note sinking sides. - Sleeps cool3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide 4/5, but its reviewer overheated; Sleep Foundation 7/10. - Motion isolation3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide 3.5/5; Sleep Foundation 7.5/10. - Trial & returns5.0
Why 5.0?
365-night trial with full refund via donation, lifetime warranty. - Durability (sagging)3.5
Why 3.5?
Sleep Foundation durability 7.5/10; Amazon owners are mixed on whether it holds its shape.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide: Best mid-range (updated 2026-05-23): pressure relief, temperature and edge 4/5, motion 3.5, value 5; too soft for stomach sleepers.
- Sleep Foundation (DreamCloud review): Full review (updated 2026-10-06, 8.5/10): durability, motion and edge 7.5; temperature and ease of movement 7.
#4
Nectar
$$Memory foamScore 3.8/5
15%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Small sample: 315 ratings (1-star 10%, 2-star 5%); may pool sizes.Tom's Guide's best memory foam mattress: a classic body-hugging feel that deadens a partner's movement, with a one-year trial and lifetime warranty for about $949 a queen. But it's too soft for stomach sleepers, cools slowly, and Amazon owners raise sagging and cooling complaints, with 15% of its small set of ratings at 1-2 stars.
Top complaints
- Too soft or not supportive enough for someVery common
Amazon's summary says comfort and back support are mixed, with some finding it too soft. Tom's Guide says it's too soft for stomach sleepers and notes the slowest foam recovery of its top picks; Sleep Foundation says stomach sleepers may need a firmer surface.
- Sagging concernsMentioned often
Amazon's summary says durability is a concern because the mattress starts to sag. Wirecutter says it is apprehensive about the long-term durability of Nectar's memory-foam mattresses.
- Runs warm for someMentioned often
Amazon owners are split on cooling, with some saying it doesn't cool at all. Sleep Foundation rates temperature 6/10, and Tom's Guide found it had the slowest cooling rate of its top six.
What owners love
- Absorbs motion
Sleep Foundation rates motion isolation 9/10; Tom's Guide scored 4/5 and says it all but deadens movement from a restless partner.
- Classic memory-foam hug for less
Tom's Guide says it delivers a Tempur-Pedic-like hug without the premium, at a perma-sale price of $949 for a queen.
- Generous policies
365-night trial with free returns after 30 nights, and a lifetime warranty with free replacement for the first 10 years (Sleep Foundation).
Skip it if…- You sleep on your stomach
- You sleep hot
- You want an easy-to-move-on, bouncy feel
Good for- Side sleepers who like a memory-foam hug
- Couples with a restless partner
- Trying a bed for a full year
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide edge 4/5 and Sleep Foundation 7.5/10, but Sleep Foundation suggests edge sitters consider a model with more edge support. - Sleeps cool3.0
Why 3.0?
Tom's Guide 3.5/5 with slow cooling; Sleep Foundation 6/10; Amazon owners split. - Motion isolation4.5
Why 4.5?
Sleep Foundation 9/10; Tom's Guide 4/5. - Trial & returns5.0
Why 5.0?
365-night trial with free returns and a lifetime warranty. - Durability (sagging)3.0
Why 3.0?
Sleep Foundation durability 7/10, but Amazon owners report sagging and Wirecutter doubts Nectar foam durability.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide: Best memory foam (updated 2026-05-23, 3.7/5): motion 4, edge 4, temperature 3.5, pressure relief 3.24; too soft for stomach sleepers.
- Sleep Foundation (Nectar Premier review): Full review (updated 2026-10-06): motion 9, edge 7.5, durability 7, temperature 6, ease of movement 6.
- Wirecutter: Brand note (updated 2026-06-23): 'worth considering' for the Nectar Classic, but apprehensive about the long-term durability of Nectar's memory foam.
#5
Bear
$$$HybridScore 3.7/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available
Tom's Guide's best cooling mattress and Sleep Foundation's pick for back pain: a 14-inch zoned hybrid in three firmnesses that shed heat fastest in Tom's Guide's lab. But Tom's Guide found weak edges and noticeable motion transfer, so it's hesitant to recommend it to couples, and Sleep Foundation's testers found it less cooling than Tom's Guide did.
Top complaints
- Weak edgesVery common
Tom's Guide gave it the lowest edge score on its list (2.5/5), noting a 'hammock' dip at the foot. Sleep Foundation rated edge support higher (7.5/10).
- Motion transferVery common
Tom's Guide found that changing position caused a lot of motion transfer (3.2/5) and is reluctant to recommend it for bed-sharing. Sleep Foundation says coil bounce can cause some motion transfer, especially on the firm model.
- Softer models and very tall buildMentioned often
Sleep Foundation says softer models lack support for back and stomach sleepers over 230 lb, and the 14-inch height may need deep-pocket sheets. It also says heat can still collect in and around the foam.
What owners love
- Sheds heat fast
Tom's Guide gave it its only 5/5 for temperature on that list, with the fastest heat-shedding rate it recorded.
- Pressure relief with lumbar zoning
Tom's Guide scored pressure relief 4.6/5 and found the medium firmness well balanced for every position. Sleep Foundation names it best for back pain (a tester rating, not a medical claim).
- Year-long trial, lifetime warranty
Bear's parent 3Z Brands now offers a 365-night trial (Tom's Guide); Sleep Foundation describes a lifetime warranty and full refund with pickup on returns.
Skip it if…- You share the bed with a restless partner
- You sit or sleep on the edge
- You don't want to buy deep-pocket sheets
Good for- Very hot sleepers and night sweats
- Choosing among soft, medium or firm
- Active people who like a hotel-bed feel
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges3.0
Why 3.0?
Tom's Guide 2.5/5 (weakest on its list) vs Sleep Foundation 7.5/10. - Sleeps cool4.5
Why 4.5?
Tom's Guide 5/5 with the fastest heat dissipation it measured; Sleep Foundation rates temperature 7/10 and says heat can still collect. - Motion isolation3.0
Why 3.0?
Tom's Guide 3.2/5 with noticeable transfer; Sleep Foundation 7/10. - Trial & returns4.5
Why 4.5?
365-night trial (Tom's Guide, Oct 2026), free return pickup and lifetime warranty (Sleep Foundation). - Durability (sagging)3.5
Why 3.5?
Sleep Foundation durability 7.5/10.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide: Best cooling (updated 2026-05-23): temperature 5, pressure relief 4.6, motion 3.2, edge 2.5; not great for couples.
- Sleep Foundation: Best for back pain (updated 2026-09-30, 8.5/10): edge 7.5, temperature 7, motion 7, durability 7.5.
#6
Leesa
$$Memory foamScore 3.4/5
16%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Small sample: 764 ratings (1-star 9%, 2-star 7%); listing title still says 120-night trial.Wirecutter's top memory-foam pick: gentle memory-foam cradle over a firm base that doesn't trap you, at about $999-$1,060 for a queen. But Sleep Foundation calls weak edges a common complaint from its testers and says it lacks support for most people over 230 lb, and Amazon owners raise smell and durability issues, with 16% of ratings at 1-2 stars.
Top complaints
- Weak edgesVery common
Sleep Foundation rates edge support 6/10, says the perimeter may buckle under weight, and calls this a common complaint from its team.
- Smell and runs warm for someMentioned often
Amazon's summary says many owners mention the smell as a significant issue, and temperature reviews are mixed, with some saying it runs hot. Sleep Foundation says it can still run warm.
- Softens or breaks down for someMentioned often
Amazon's summary says durability is mixed, with some saying it broke down after 3-4 years. Sleep Foundation rates durability 6.5/10 and says sleepers over about 200 lb tend to call it too soft.
What owners love
- Cradles without sinking
Wirecutter says it combines the gentle cradle of memory foam with an underlying firmness, so it hugs you without hampering movement.
- Good motion isolation
Sleep Foundation rates motion isolation 8/10 and says you'll barely notice movement on the other side of the bed.
- Value and long trial
Wirecutter calls it a great value at about $1,000 for a queen. Leesa now lists a 365-night trial and a limited lifetime warranty.
Skip it if…- You weigh more than about 230 lb
- You sit on the edge of the bed a lot
- You're sensitive to new-mattress smells
Good for- Memory-foam feel that's easy to move on
- Couples (good motion isolation)
- Sleepers under about 230 lb
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges2.5
Why 2.5?
Sleep Foundation edge 6/10; the perimeter may buckle. - Sleeps cool3.0
Why 3.0?
Sleep Foundation temperature 7/10 but can run warm; Amazon owners mixed. - Motion isolation4.0
Why 4.0?
Sleep Foundation 8/10. - Trial & returns4.5
Why 4.5?
Leesa lists a 365-night trial and lifetime warranty; Wirecutter says returns are free after 30 days (two returns per household). - Durability (sagging)3.0
Why 3.0?
Sleep Foundation durability 6.5/10; some Amazon owners report it breaking down after 3-4 years.
What experts say
- Wirecutter: Top pick for memory foam (updated 2026-06-23): cradling memory foam that doesn't sink; about $1,000 for a queen.
- Sleep Foundation (Leesa review): Full review (updated 2026-10-08, 8.2/10): motion 8, temperature 7, durability 6.5, edge 6; inadequate support for most over 230 lb.
#7
Novilla
$Memory foamScore 3.3/5
9%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Listing pools sizes and the 6- to 14-inch versions (28,616 ratings; 1-star 6%, 2-star 3%).Wirecutter's budget memory-foam pick and a heavily reviewed Amazon bed: a Tempur-Pedic-like sink with solid edges and great motion isolation for about $300 a queen. But its top foam is low-density, which Wirecutter says suggests it won't last as long, it's hard to shift positions on, and Amazon owners report mixed firmness, back support and expansion.
Top complaints
- Firmness and back support are mixedVery common
Amazon's summary says firmness is mixed, with some saying it's too firm, and back support is mixed, with some reporting severe back pain. Wirecutter says it's not especially soft.
- Doesn't always expand fullyMentioned often
Amazon's summary says inflation experiences are mixed, with some reporting poor expansion.
- Low-density top layerMentioned often
Wirecutter says its top memory-foam layer is an underwhelming 1.9 lb per cubic foot, which suggests it won't be as durable as mattresses with denser foam. Several Wirecutter testers found shifting positions difficult.
What owners love
- Tempur-Pedic-like feel for less
Wirecutter testers who like a quicksand-like sink especially liked its body-conforming feel.
- Great motion isolation and solid edges
Wirecutter says it would easily pass the wine-glass test and has solid edge support.
- Cheap and popular
About $300 for a queen (Wirecutter), with a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty. Amazon's summary says owners find it comfortable and well worth the money.
Skip it if…- You want a mattress to last many years
- You change positions often
- You want a soft, plush feel
Good for- Tight budgets and guest rooms
- Fans of a slow memory-foam sink
- Co-sleeping with a restless partner
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges3.5
Why 3.5?
Wirecutter says it has solid edge support; an Amazon reviewer says it's surprisingly good but still not like a spring mattress. - Motion isolation4.0
Why 4.0?
Wirecutter calls its motion isolation great. - Trial & returns3.0
Why 3.0?
100-night trial and 10-year warranty; Wirecutter notes free returns only 'under specific circumstances'. - Durability (sagging)2.5
Why 2.5?
Wirecutter says the 1.9 lb/cu ft top foam suggests below-average durability.
What experts say
- Wirecutter (best cheap mattresses): Top pick, conforming memory-foam feel (updated 2026-06-23): solid edges and motion isolation; not especially soft, hard to shift on, so-so foam density.
- Wirecutter: Listed among Wirecutter's best budget mattresses at a $280 street price for a queen.
#8
Zinus
$Memory foamScore 2.7/5
11%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)10-inch listing, pooling sizes (22,327 ratings; 1-star 8%, 2-star 3%). The larger 12-inch listing (B0CKYZC93L, 91,523 ratings) shows 12%.A perennial Amazon best seller that Tom's Guide calls one of the best cheap beds: a soft, marshmallowy foam hug that absorbs motion, for $599 list (usually $499 or less) for a queen. But the edges are very weak, it can sleep warm, owners question its durability, and buying on Amazon means no trial. Wirecutter has dropped it as a pick.
Top complaints
- Very weak edgesVery common
Tom's Guide scored edge support 2.5/5: a tester nearly slid off, and a 50 lb weight wouldn't balance closer than about eight inches from the edge. It says Amazon customers also find edge support lacking.
- Firmness and back comfort are hit-or-missVery common
Amazon's summary says firmness gets mixed feedback (some say too firm) and back pain experiences are mixed. Tom's Guide found it too soft for most back and stomach sleepers. Wirecutter, which dropped it as a pick, preferred its newer foam picks in testing.
- Sagging, warmth and smellMentioned often
Tom's Guide says some customers noticed sagging after limited use, and it expects shorter life from a budget bed. Testers woke up warm (3/5) and noticed a strong paint-like smell that faded quickly. Amazon owners are split on odor.
What owners love
- Plush pressure relief for side sleepers
Tom's Guide gave pressure relief 4/5 and compared it to a Tempur-Pedic-style hug; all its side-sleeping testers enjoyed it.
- Excellent motion isolation
Tom's Guide gave motion isolation 4.5/5: a wine glass stayed upright in its drop tests.
- Cheap and widely loved
Queen MSRP is $599 and it usually sells for $499 direct, often lower on Amazon (Tom's Guide). Amazon's summary says owners find it comfortable and well worth the price.
Skip it if…- You need firm edges to sit or get up
- You sleep hot or on your stomach
- You want it to last many years
Good for- Side sleepers on a tight budget
- Guest rooms
- Couples who want little motion transfer
Scores (tap for why)
- Support & edges2.0
Why 2.0?
Tom's Guide edge 2.5/5 ('very weak edges'); customers also find edges lacking. - Sleeps cool2.5
Why 2.5?
Tom's Guide temperature 3/5; the tester woke warm most mornings. - Motion isolation4.5
Why 4.5?
Tom's Guide 4.5/5, on par with the Nectar Premier. - Trial & returns2.5
Why 2.5?
100-night trial and 10-year warranty buying direct from Zinus; bought on Amazon, it can only be returned if faulty (Tom's Guide). - Durability (sagging)2.0
Why 2.0?
Some customers report sagging after limited use; Tom's Guide expects decreased longevity from a budget mattress.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide (Zinus review): Full review: one of the best cheap beds for side sleepers; motion 4.5, pressure relief 4, temperature 3, edge 2.5. The Siena is stronger at a similar price.
- Wirecutter (best cheap mattresses): Former pick (updated 2026-06-23): nicer-feeling memory foam with a classic sink, but newer foam picks got more positive tester feedback.