ConsFirst / Pillows
Pillows: the downsides, first
Pillow comfort is personal, and expert testers often disagree about how firm or cool the same pillow feels. Here are the most popular pillows in the US, with owner complaints about flattening, heat and smell up front.
8 models compared15 sources readUpdated October 2026
We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more
All 8 pillows, ranked
Ranked by test scores, minus how common and serious the complaints are. How we rank
#1
Coop Sleep Goods (Coop Home Goods)
$$Shredded memory foamScore 3.9/5
7%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Queen listing linked from Wirecutter (64,024 ratings); may pool sizes.The pick experts agree on most often: Wirecutter, Good Housekeeping and Tom's Guide all chose it, and CNN named it best for back sleepers. You can add or remove fill, and the whole pillow is washable. The downsides are an off-gassing smell some owners notice, a thin cover, and warmth for hot sleepers.
Top complaints
- Chemical smell out of the boxMentioned often
Amazon's summary says several customers report an awful smell. One of the six Coop pillows Wirecutter ordered had a strong off-gassing smell for several days; the other five had no noticeable scent.
- Can run warmMentioned often
Tom's Guide lists it as not for chronic hot sleepers. A Wirecutter reader said they wake up with a sweaty head on it, though CNN found it kept them cool and dry on warm nights.
- Thin cover that pillsMentioned often
Good Housekeeping saw the polyester/rayon cover pill after laundering and use. Wirecutter found the cover thinner and less resilient than others, and CNN's cat clawed holes in the thin knit cover of the Crescent version.
- Needs fluffing; adjusting is messyMentioned often
Tom's Guide says it needs regular fluffing to keep its shape and support. Good Housekeeping found adjusting the fill a bit messy.
What owners love
- Works for most sleep positions
Good Housekeeping's 10+ testers across side, back and stomach sleeping all said it improved their sleep. Wirecutter testers felt 'cradled without sinking', and CNN called it the best for back sleepers.
- Adjustable fill that holds its shape
It comes with an extra bag of fill. Wirecutter found it held its shape better than other shredded pillows, with no hard, flat pancakes, and it bounced back immediately in Good Housekeeping's lab.
- Fully washable, long trial
The cover and fill are machine-washable and dryer-safe, and Good Housekeeping saw no shrinkage after five washes. There's a 100-night trial and a five-year warranty (Wirecutter, Tom's Guide).
Skip it if…- You are very sensitive to new-foam smells
- You sleep very hot
- You don't want to fluff or adjust a pillow
Good for- Fine-tuning height to your sleep position
- Combination sleepers
- A fully machine-washable foam pillow
Scores (tap for why)
- Support4.5
Why 4.5?
Top pick at Wirecutter, Good Housekeeping and Tom's Guide for support across positions; Tom's Guide notes it needs regular fluffing. - Cooling3.0
Why 3.0?
CNN found it breathable, but Tom's Guide says it's not for chronic hot sleepers and a Wirecutter reader wakes up sweaty. - Adjustable loft5.0
Why 5.0?
Fully adjustable fill, with an extra bag of fill included. - Smell & off-gassing3.0
Why 3.0?
One of six Wirecutter units smelled strongly for days, and Amazon's summary says several customers report an awful smell. - Durability & washing4.0
Why 4.0?
The cover and fill are machine-washable and dryable with no shrinkage after five washes (Good Housekeeping); five-year warranty; the cover pills and is thin.
What experts say
- Wirecutter (NYT): Best adjustable memory-foam pillow (updated 2026-07-14): fluffy, supportive and fully washable; the cover is thinner than others, and one of six units smelled strongly.
- Good Housekeeping: Best overall (updated 2026-09-22): improved sleep for every tester; the cover pilled over time.
- Tom's Guide: Best overall (updated 2026-10-06): medium-firm for all positions; not for chronic hot sleepers, and needs regular fluffing.
- CNN Underscored: Best for back sleepers: kept its shape and fluffiness and survived multiple wash-and-dry cycles.
#2
Saatva
$$$LatexScore 4.0/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available
Tom's Guide's best hotel-luxury pick, scoring 5/5 on support, cooling and setup, with shredded natural latex wrapped in down-alternative fiber. The catches are $165+ pricing, a one-year warranty and 45-night trial, a latex core that can't be washed, and some buyers who find it too firm. It's sold only by Saatva.
Top complaints
- Expensive, short warrantyMentioned often
It starts at $165 and is rarely on sale except in pairs. Tom's Guide calls the 45-night trial and one-year warranty meager for the price.
- Too firm for someOccasional
Tom's Guide says the few negative Saatva.com reviews include buyers who found it too firm or not soft enough.
- Latex core isn't washable; no fill adjustmentMentioned often
The cover and fiber layer wash, but the shredded latex core must be removed first. You choose between two lofts but can't adjust the fill.
What owners love
- Sleeps cool
Tom's Guide's tester, a hot sleeper, never woke up hot, scoring it 5/5 for temperature.
- Plush but supportive, no re-fluffing
Head and neck stayed aligned for side and stomach sleeping, and Tom's Guide never had to re-fluff it.
- No off-gassing, two lofts
It isn't shrink-wrapped, so there's no off-gassing concern, and it comes in standard (4-5 in) or high (6-7 in) loft.
Skip it if…- You want to adjust the fill yourself
- You're on a budget
- You want a long warranty
Good for- Hot sleepers who want a plush feel
- Side and combination sleepers (high loft)
- Avoiding foam smells
Scores (tap for why)
- Support4.5
Why 4.5?
5/5 for firmness and support in Tom's Guide's test; a few Saatva.com buyers find it too firm. - Cooling4.5
Why 4.5?
5/5 for temperature regulation in Tom's Guide's test (hot-sleeping tester). - Adjustable loft3.0
Why 3.0?
Two loft options but no adjustable fill. - Smell & off-gassing4.5
Why 4.5?
Not shrink-wrapped; Tom's Guide had no off-gassing concerns. - Durability & washing3.5
Why 3.5?
The cover and fiber layer are washable and the gussets hold its shape, but the latex core isn't washable and the warranty is only one year.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide: Best hotel luxury pillow (updated 2026-10-06): two lofts, stays fluffy, naturally cooling; not machine-washable.
- Tom's Guide (Saatva Latex review): 5/5 on every parameter: excellent support and cooling; pricey with a one-year warranty, and the latex core can't be washed.
#3
Layla Sleep
$$Shredded memory foamScore 3.9/5
Amazon 1–2 star share
not available
An adjustable memory-foam-and-kapok pillow that Good Housekeeping and Tom's Guide both picked, mainly for support that doesn't flatten. The experts disagree on how it feels, though: Good Housekeeping found it softer and lower, for back and stomach sleepers, while Tom's Guide found it medium-firm and best for side sleepers.
Top complaints
- Not a cooling pillowMentioned often
Tom's Guide found it sleeps neutral but woke up hot and stuffy one warm morning, and recommends a dedicated cooling pillow for hot sleepers.
- Firmer than some expect, and needs tuningMentioned often
Tom's Guide's tester found it too firm at first and removed about a quarter of the fill; stomach sleepers have to remove much more. (Good Housekeeping instead describes it as medium-soft.)
- Gray cover shows through; inner fill spot-clean onlyOccasional
Good Housekeeping notes the gray cover can show through white pillowcases. Tom's Guide says the cover is washable but the inner fill is spot-clean only.
What owners love
- Supportive and keeps its shape
Good Housekeeping's consumer testers gave it perfect scores for comfort and support, and it bounced back in the lab. Tom's Guide found it didn't flatten or shift during the night.
- Adjustable, natural-fiber fill
A shredded memory foam and kapok blend you can remove (a storage bag is included), with CertiPUR-US foam and an Oeko-Tex cover (Tom's Guide).
- Good benefits
30-night trial, five-year warranty and free shipping and returns (Tom's Guide).
Skip it if…- You sleep very hot
- You want a fully machine-washable pillow
- You want more than a 30-night trial
Good for- Adjustable support that doesn't flatten
- Shoppers who want a natural-fiber blend
- Side or back sleepers
Scores (tap for why)
- Support4.0
Why 4.0?
Perfect comfort and support scores from Good Housekeeping's testers; Tom's Guide found its support consistent and its shape held. - Cooling3.0
Why 3.0?
Neutral (3.5/5) in Tom's Guide's test; breathable but not cooling. - Adjustable loft4.5
Why 4.5?
Fully adjustable fill with a storage bag included. - Smell & off-gassing4.5
Why 4.5?
No noticeable smell during expansion in Tom's Guide's test. - Durability & washing3.5
Why 3.5?
Tom's Guide scored build 5/5 and there's a five-year warranty, but only the cover is machine-washable.
What experts say
- Good Housekeeping: Best for back and stomach sleepers: plush, adjustable and lower profile; the gray cover can show through white pillowcases.
- Tom's Guide: Best for neck pain: firm, adjustable support that doesn't flatten like the Coop; breathable but not cooling.
- Tom's Guide (Layla Kapok review): Review: best suited to side and back sleepers; stomach sleepers must remove a lot of fill; neutral temperature.
#4
Purple
$$$LatexScore 3.4/5
13%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)7,154 ratings pooled across lofts and sizes.A Talalay latex core wrapped in Purple's gel grid, picked by Good Housekeeping for hot sleepers and by Tom's Guide for back sleepers. But Tom's Guide's own reviewer still slept warm, the mesh cover snags, the price is over $200, and the trial is now only 30 nights.
Top complaints
- Cooling doesn't work for everyoneMentioned often
Tom's Guide's reviewer slept warm most nights and often woke with a sweaty head and neck. Some Purple customers say they flip it to find a cool spot. Good Housekeeping's hot-sleeper testers, by contrast, all said it slept cooler.
- Shape and durability are mixedMentioned often
Amazon's summary says some owners find it goes flat or breaks down over time, while others say it holds its shape.
- Expensive, short trial, and a snag-prone coverMentioned often
List price is $209-$249 (Tom's Guide), the trial dropped from 100 to 30 nights, and the warranty is one year. Tom's Guide found pulls in the mesh cover.
- Wrong loft can cause neck painOccasional
Tom's Guide says neck-pain complaints in customer reviews are often tied to choosing a pillow too high or too low.
What owners love
- Supportive yet soft
Good Housekeeping found the latex core gives strong neck support and returned to shape perfectly after 8 hours of weights. Tom's Guide found it cradled the head, neck and shoulders.
- Three lofts
Low, medium and tall versions suit different frames and positions (Good Housekeeping, Tom's Guide).
- Breathable for many sleepers
All of Good Housekeeping's hot-sleeper testers said it slept cooler than their previous pillow, and Amazon owners appreciate its cooling.
Skip it if…- You're on a budget
- You want an adjustable fill
- You sleep extremely hot
Good for- Side or back sleepers who like a soft, bouncy feel
- Choosing among three lofts
- People who find memory foam too warm
Scores (tap for why)
- Support4.0
Why 4.0?
Strong neck support and perfect shape recovery in Good Housekeeping's lab; Amazon owners are mixed on shape retention. - Cooling3.5
Why 3.5?
Good Housekeeping's hot sleepers all slept cooler, but Tom's Guide's reviewer slept warm. - Adjustable loft3.0
Why 3.0?
Not adjustable, but sold in three lofts. - Smell & off-gassing3.5
Why 3.5?
No obvious smell for Tom's Guide, but some Purple customers report a short-lived plastic odor. - Durability & washing3.0
Why 3.0?
Cover looked nearly new after five washes (Good Housekeeping) but isn't dryer-safe; inner core spot-clean; mesh pulls; one-year warranty; mixed durability on Amazon.
What experts say
- Good Housekeeping: Best for hot sleepers: latex core and grid stay cool and supportive; the cover isn't dryer-safe.
- Tom's Guide: Best for back sleepers: soft, responsive, sleeps cool for most; listed as spot-clean only.
- Tom's Guide (Purple Harmony review): Review: great for side sleepers; the reviewer still slept warm, the mesh cover pulls, and the trial was cut to 30 nights.
#5
Tempur-Pedic
$$Solid memory foamScore 3.1/5
10%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Standard listing (7,587 ratings), shared with the 2-pack and other sizes.A soft, low (about 5 in) slab of Tempur foam that Tom's Guide likes for stomach and back sleepers. But it's too thin for side sleepers, can trap heat, and needs kneading to clear dents, and Amazon owners complain it goes flat.
Top complaints
- Too thin and goes flatVery common
Amazon's summary says the pillow is not very thick and goes extremely flat when you lie on it. Tom's Guide found it too thin for side sleeping, and its tester's head slipped forward, twisting the neck.
- Mixed supportVery common
Amazon owners are mixed: some report great neck support, others little to no support.
- Can trap heatMentioned often
Tom's Guide rated temperature control 3/5: neutral most nights, but uncomfortably warm when the tester had a fever.
- Slow-recovering dentsMentioned often
Tom's Guide's weight test took seven seconds to recover, and indentations sometimes needed kneading or flipping to clear.
What owners love
- Neutral alignment for stomach and back sleeping
Tom's Guide's stomach-sleeping tester had no neck aches, and its soft foam meant no pressure at the ear or jaw. It won Tom's Guide's 2025 award for stomach sleepers.
- No off-gassing
It ships unrolled, not vacuum-packed, and Tom's Guide noticed no off-gassing.
- Five-year warranty and a quality cover
Tom's Guide found the quilted cover soft and luxe, and the warranty among the best for a pillow.
Skip it if…- You sleep on your side
- You sleep hot
- You want a lofty, fluffy pillow
Good for- Stomach sleepers
- Back sleepers who want a lower pillow
- Travel (it rolls up)
Scores (tap for why)
- Support3.0
Why 3.0?
Good for back and stomach (Tom's Guide 4/5 for those positions), too thin for side sleepers; Amazon owners are mixed and say it goes flat. - Cooling2.5
Why 2.5?
Tom's Guide rated temperature control 3/5 and says it can sleep hot; a cooling version costs extra. - Adjustable loft1.5
Why 1.5?
One fixed, roughly 5-inch loft. - Smell & off-gassing5.0
Why 5.0?
No off-gassing in Tom's Guide's test (it isn't vacuum-packed). - Durability & washing3.5
Why 3.5?
Held up well over a month with a five-year warranty, but the foam is spot-clean only and dents need kneading.
What experts say
- Tom's Guide (Tempur-Cloud review): 4/5: great for stomach and back sleepers; too thin for side sleepers, and it can trap heat.
- Tom's Guide: Also recommended for back and front sleepers; replaced as Tom's Guide's memory foam pick because it's too thin for side sleeping.
#6
Beckham Hotel Collection
$Down alternativeScore 2.9/5
9%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)264,611 ratings, pooled across sizes.Amazon's mega-seller is about $30 a pillow: soft and hotel-like, with a cotton cover, and Good Housekeeping's best value. But Tom's Guide found it flattens quickly and Amazon owners agree, Wirecutter found it squishy and unsupportive, and there's no trial or warranty.
Top complaints
- Goes flat quicklyVery common
Amazon's summary says customers are disappointed that the pillows go completely flat quickly. Tom's Guide's 10 lb weight almost flattened it, and the fill compressed so much that the tester woke up to readjust it.
- Not enough support for someVery common
Wirecutter testers found it squishy and said it didn't contour well. Some of Good Housekeeping's side-sleeper testers found it lacked support, and Amazon owners are split between very supportive and no neck support.
- Loose threads after washing; no warrantyMentioned often
Good Housekeeping's analysts saw loose threads and puckering after washing. Tom's Guide notes there is no sleep trial or warranty, and that washing the whole pillow (no removable cover) is tedious.
What owners love
- Big value
About $30 per pillow in a two-pack (Good Housekeeping, Tom's Guide), with a cotton cover that looks pricier than it is.
- Kept its shape in the lab
Unlike many soft pillows, it bounced back well after Good Housekeeping's compression tests, and the fill stayed evenly distributed for its testers.
- Sleeps temperature-neutral
Tom's Guide found it neutral thanks to the cotton cover, and Amazon's summary says customers stay cool.
Skip it if…- You need firm neck support
- You want a pillow that lasts
- You switch positions a lot
Good for- Guest beds on a budget
- People who like a soft, fluffy pillow
- Back sleepers who want plushness
Scores (tap for why)
- Support2.5
Why 2.5?
Held shape in Good Housekeeping's lab, but Tom's Guide found it flattens fast, Wirecutter called it squishy, and Amazon owners complain it goes flat. - Cooling3.5
Why 3.5?
Temperature-neutral for Tom's Guide (4/5) and cool per Amazon owners; no active cooling. - Adjustable loft1.5
Why 1.5?
A single, non-adjustable fill and loft. - Smell & off-gassing4.5
Why 4.5?
Tom's Guide noticed no off-gassing on unboxing. - Durability & washing2.5
Why 2.5?
Fully machine-washable, but Tom's Guide rates durability 3/5, Good Housekeeping saw loose threads after washing, and there's no warranty.
What experts say
- Good Housekeeping: Best value: fluffy and easy to clean, kept its shape in lab tests; loose threads and puckering after washing.
- Tom's Guide (Beckham review): 3.6/5 (2025-11-25): instant plush comfort and good for guest beds, but it flattens quickly and has no trial or warranty.
- Wirecutter (NYT): Dismissed (Amazon's most popular bed pillow): squishy, didn't contour well, 'middle of the road', maybe fine for a guest room.
#7
Brooklinen
$$$Down / featherScore 3.0/5
17%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Only 21 ratings (king, firm listing); too small a sample to rely on.Wirecutter's top-ranked down pillow for comfort: a feather core inside down for firm support, with a quiet sateen cover and a 365-day return window. But it's mostly feathers (600 fill power), less moldable than high-down pillows, and Brooklinen recommends commercial machines for washing.
Top complaints
- Mostly feathers, lower fill powerMentioned often
The core is primarily feathers and the down is only 600 fill power, below Wirecutter's threshold, making it less moldable than high-down pillows.
- Commercial washing recommendedMentioned often
Brooklinen recommends washing and drying only in commercial machines; home washing works but may take longer (Wirecutter).
- Return feeOccasional
Returns are allowed within a year, but a $9.95 restocking fee is deducted.
What owners love
- Highest comfort among down pillows
Side, back and stomach sleepers all liked the firm version, describing it as fluffy with great contouring around the head and neck.
- Quality materials
A quiet, Oeko-Tex-certified 400-thread-count cotton sateen cover and Downmark-certified ethical down.
- Long return window, try in stores
365-day returns and eight retail stores to try it; two-year warranty.
Skip it if…- You want a soft, moldable down pillow
- You want easy home washing
- You have feather allergies
Good for- Down lovers who need firmer support
- Trying before buying (stores, 365-day returns)
- Ethically sourced down
Scores (tap for why)
- Support4.0
Why 4.0?
Supportive enough for back and side sleepers thanks to the feather core, per Wirecutter testers. - Adjustable loft2.0
Why 2.0?
Not adjustable; sold in soft, medium and firm, and the feather core is less moldable. - Durability & washing3.0
Why 3.0?
High-quality cover and a two-year warranty, but commercial washing is recommended.
What experts say
- Wirecutter (NYT): Top pick (updated 2026-07-14): most comfortable down pillow, supportive enough for side sleepers; mostly feathers, 600 fill power, and commercial washing is recommended.
#8
Tempur-Pedic
$$Solid memory foamScore 3.0/5
19%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)TEMPUR-Ergo Neck medium listing (8,054 ratings), pooled with other sizes and the TEMPUR-Neck 2-pack.A firm, contoured foam pillow that Good Housekeeping picked for neck support and Tom's Guide picked for side sleepers. But it's very firm, runs warm, is small, and has the highest Amazon low-star share here, with owners split on firmness and pain relief.
Top complaints
- Too firm for someVery common
Good Housekeeping says it's much firmer than its other picks and took time to adjust to. Amazon's summary calls firmness mixed, with some finding it too firm.
- Mixed comfort and pain relief; small sizeVery common
Amazon's summary says pain relief and comfort are mixed, with some owners experiencing discomfort, and the size is criticized as too small. Good Housekeeping and Tom's Guide note it fits awkwardly in a pillowcase.
- Runs warmMentioned often
Tom's Guide lists poor cooling and says it lacks active cooling or breathable features.
- Not for stomach sleepingMentioned often
Tom's Guide says it isn't suitable for side sleepers who also sleep on their stomach.
What owners love
- Strong neck support
Good Housekeeping's testers said it helped with their neck pain, and Tom's Guide's testers found it stable and firm, keeping its shape over time.
- Three sizes for different frames
Small, medium and large profiles (3.5 to 4.75 in per Tom's Guide).
- Shape-stable foam with a long warranty
It kept its shape after Good Housekeeping's pressure tests, though it took time to recover, and it has a five-year warranty (Tom's Guide).
Skip it if…- You like a soft or squishy pillow
- You sleep hot
- You also sleep on your stomach
Good for- Side and back sleepers who like firm support
- A contoured neck shape
- Shoppers who want a five-year warranty
Scores (tap for why)
- Support4.0
Why 4.0?
Expert picks for neck and side support (Good Housekeeping, Tom's Guide); Amazon owners are mixed on firmness and comfort. - Cooling2.0
Why 2.0?
Tom's Guide: poor cooling properties, with no active cooling or breathable features. - Adjustable loft2.5
Why 2.5?
Not adjustable, but sold in three profile sizes. - Durability & washing3.5
Why 3.5?
Stable foam that kept its shape in Good Housekeeping's tests and a five-year warranty; the foam can't be washed and the cover must hang to dry.
What experts say
- Good Housekeeping: Best for neck support: contoured, stable foam; may be too firm for some, foam not washable, cover not dryer-safe.
- Tom's Guide: Best for side sleepers: ergonomic and firm; poor cooling.