ConsFirst / Pillows

Brooklinen

Brooklinen Down Pillow: the downsides first

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more

#7 of 8
$$$Down / featherScore 3.0/5
17%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)Only 21 ratings (king, firm listing); too small a sample to rely on.

Wirecutter's top-ranked down pillow for comfort: a feather core inside down for firm support, with a quiet sateen cover and a 365-day return window. But it's mostly feathers (600 fill power), less moldable than high-down pillows, and Brooklinen recommends commercial machines for washing.

Top complaints

  • Mostly feathers, lower fill power

    The core is primarily feathers and the down is only 600 fill power, below Wirecutter's threshold, making it less moldable than high-down pillows.

    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
  • Commercial washing recommended

    Brooklinen recommends washing and drying only in commercial machines; home washing works but may take longer (Wirecutter).

    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
  • Return fee

    Returns are allowed within a year, but a $9.95 restocking fee is deducted.

    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)

What owners love

  • Highest comfort among down pillows

    Side, back and stomach sleepers all liked the firm version, describing it as fluffy with great contouring around the head and neck.

    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
  • Quality materials

    A quiet, Oeko-Tex-certified 400-thread-count cotton sateen cover and Downmark-certified ethical down.

    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
  • Long return window, try in stores

    365-day returns and eight retail stores to try it; two-year warranty.

    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
Good for
  • Down lovers who need firmer support
  • Trying before buying (stores, 365-day returns)
  • Ethically sourced down

Scores (tap for why)

  • Support4.0
    Why 4.0?Supportive enough for back and side sleepers thanks to the feather core, per Wirecutter testers.
    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
  • Adjustable loft2.0
    Why 2.0?Not adjustable; sold in soft, medium and firm, and the feather core is less moldable.
    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)
  • Durability & washing3.0
    Why 3.0?High-quality cover and a two-year warranty, but commercial washing is recommended.
    Source: Wirecutter (NYT)

What experts say

  • Wirecutter (NYT): Top pick (updated 2026-07-14): most comfortable down pillow, supportive enough for side sleepers; mostly feathers, 600 fill power, and commercial washing is recommended.
Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.

If that catch is a deal-breaker

Highly ranked pillows whose biggest complaint is something else.

#1 in pillowsCoop Original Adjustable Pillow

The pick experts agree on most often: Wirecutter, Good Housekeeping and Tom's Guide all chose it, and CNN named it best for back sleepers. You can add or remove fill, and the whole pillow is washable. The downsides are an off-gassing smell some owners notice, a thin cover, and warmth for hot sleepers.

Its catch: chemical smell out of the box#2 in pillowsSaatva Latex Pillow

Tom's Guide's best hotel-luxury pick, scoring 5/5 on support, cooling and setup, with shredded natural latex wrapped in down-alternative fiber. The catches are $165+ pricing, a one-year warranty and 45-night trial, a latex core that can't be washed, and some buyers who find it too firm. It's sold only by Saatva.

Its catch: expensive, short warranty#3 in pillowsLayla Kapok Pillow

An adjustable memory-foam-and-kapok pillow that Good Housekeeping and Tom's Guide both picked, mainly for support that doesn't flatten. The experts disagree on how it feels, though: Good Housekeeping found it softer and lower, for back and stomach sleepers, while Tom's Guide found it medium-firm and best for side sleepers.

Its catch: not a cooling pillow

See all 8 pillows ranked →