ConsFirst / Smartwatches & fitness trackers

Google

Google Pixel Watch 4: the downsides first

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links. It never changes what we report. Learn more

#1 of 8
$$$SmartwatchAndroid onlyScore 3.9/5
11%
of Amazon ratings are 1–2 stars
(checked 2026-10-10)1,408 ratings (under 1,500), on the 45 mm Wi-Fi listing.

Tom's Guide's best smartwatch for Android, with a bright display, dual-band GPS and about two days per charge on the 45 mm model. Wirecutter has moved to the Pixel Watch 5 but says the 4 has the same hardware. About 1 in 9 Amazon ratings are 1 or 2 stars, and owners disagree on battery and heart-rate accuracy.

Top complaints

  • Battery and value split owners

    Amazon's review summary says battery life and value for money get mixed reviews, with some owners saying the battery only lasts a couple of days and others saying it isn't worth the price. Tom's Guide, by contrast, got close to 60 hours on the 45 mm model.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say), Tom's Guide (best smartwatches)
  • Heart-rate accuracy questioned

    Amazon's review summary says customers disagree on how accurate the heart-rate tracking is. Tom's Guide calls the fitness and health updates incremental.

    Source: Amazon.com product page (Customers say), Tom's Guide review
  • New charger, and SOS only on LTE

    Tom's Guide lists incompatibility with older chargers as a con, along with satellite SOS messaging being limited to the pricier LTE models.

    Source: Tom's Guide review, Tom's Guide (best smartwatches)

What owners love

  • Long battery for a full smartwatch

    Google rates 40 hours for the 45 mm model, and Tom's Guide got closer to 60, nearly three times the Apple Watch Series 10.

    Source: Tom's Guide (best smartwatches)
  • Accurate step counting and dual-band GPS

    Tom's Guide found it just 29 steps off a manual count and praises the dual-band GPS for cities and remote areas.

    Source: Tom's Guide (best smartwatches)
  • Repairable and works with any Android phone

    Tom's Guide says it's the first Pixel Watch with a replaceable battery and display, and only a few features are Pixel-exclusive. Amazon owners praise easy setup and pairing.

    Source: Tom's Guide (best smartwatches), Amazon.com product page (Customers say)
Good for
  • Android users on any brand of phone
  • Two days between charges (45 mm)
  • People who want a repairable watch (replaceable battery and screen)

Scores (tap for why)

What experts say

  • Tom's Guide: Best smartwatch for Android (updated 2026-09-21). The cons are incompatibility with older chargers and SOS messaging only on LTE models.
  • Tom's Guide review: Praises the bigger, brighter screen, class-leading battery and Gemini, but calls the health and fitness updates incremental.
  • Wirecutter (NYT): A former pick, replaced by the Pixel Watch 5. It has the exact same external hardware and almost the same health features; Wirecutter recommends waiting for a sale.
Check price on AmazonWe don't list prices — they change daily. Paid link.

If that catch is a deal-breaker

Highly ranked smartwatches & fitness trackers whose biggest complaint is something else.

#2 in smartwatches & fitness trackersGarmin Forerunner 165

A budget Garmin running watch with an AMOLED screen and GPS and heart-rate accuracy that Android Central found as good as pricier Forerunners, plus about 11 days of battery. It holds back Training Load and Training Status, music costs extra, and it's a fitness watch first, not a full smartwatch.

Its catch: key training features held back#3 in smartwatches & fitness trackersApple Watch Ultra 4

The longest-lasting Apple Watch, with multi-day battery life, dual-frequency GPS, a dive depth sensor and satellite messaging in a rugged titanium case. At $799 and 49 mm, Wirecutter calls it too much watch for most people and only a minor upgrade over the Ultra 3.

Its catch: huge and uncomfortable for smaller wrists#4 in smartwatches & fitness trackersAmazfit Active 3 Premium

Tom's Guide's best smartwatch overall: about a week-plus of battery, Garmin-like running features, offline maps and a sapphire screen for around $140, on any phone. It lacks the safety alerts, apps and polish of Apple and Google watches, and heart-rate tracking struggles on hard efforts.

Its catch: limited smartwatch features

Head-to-head

See all 8 smartwatches & fitness trackers ranked →